Armor Is Blocking a Website and Unblocking on Orbi App Doesn't fix It

Hi,

Up until yesterday I had no problem with a website that I login into for work.  This morning when I tried I got the following error:

Stop!

Netgear Armor has blocked this website for your protection, it might contain malware, phishing, fraud attempt, or other forms of criminal...

We suggest you go back to safety

I would also get the following pop-up on my Orbi App:

Privacy Threat Blocked

Netgear Armor has detected that your computer is sending unencrypted authentication information and blocked that page.  

When I click 'unblock URL' it says the URL was unblocked successfully but won't let me proceed to the website.  

The only thing that fixed it was disabling Netgear Armor but I don't want that as the long-term solution, what else can I do?