NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.
Forum Discussion
Reagten
Sep 11, 2017Aspirant
Does the Orbi have ethernet backhaul?
We need to buy a mesh system NOW. I like that the Orbi gets the highest marks for performance on many review sites, but if it doesn't support ethernet backhaul, then this is a deal breaker. No, ...
Reagten
Sep 11, 2017Aspirant
Do access points allow seamless hand off from one AP to another?
TheEther
Sep 12, 2017Guru
Reagten wrote:
Do access points allow seamless hand off from one AP to another?
Leaving enterprise gear out of the discussion, keep in mind that hand off is generally decided by the device, not by the access point. AFAIK, even the Orbi won't initiate hand off of a device between satellites.
Whether or not the hand off is seamless really depends on the aggressiveness of the device's roaming algorithm. Most smartphones are not aggressive; they are very sticky. This often results in a poor handoff experience.
The hand off experience will also depend on the placement of the access points. Place them too closely and a device may not roam. Too far apart and there will be dead spots. I've seen recommendations in some enterprise guides for 15%-20% overlap between Wi-Fi cells, where the edge of each cell is -67 dBm.
Some consumer grade access points are now starting to support the trio of protocols, 802.11r/k/v, to facilitate fast BSS transition (aka fast roaming) but these are really designed to combat the high costs of hand off in an enterprise setting. In a home environment, they may not offer much or any improvement. In addition, a few brands do offer a minimum RSSI setting that will kick a device off in order to force it to roam. But this can hardly be considered a seamless hand off!
- thebishopSep 13, 2017Apprentice
"
First off, Orbi is not really a mesh system. In a mesh system, a satellite can send traffic through another satellite. Orbi can't do that. All satellites must connect to the base station."
Actually, now with 2.0 firmware it is. As Daisy-Chaining was enabled.
- peteytestingSep 13, 2017Hero
yup
thebishop wrote:
"
First off, Orbi is not really a mesh system. In a mesh system, a satellite can send traffic through another satellite. Orbi can't do that. All satellites must connect to the base station."
Actually, now with 2.0 firmware it is. As Daisy-Chaining was enabled.
yup and it works , not exactly mesh but dam close
- TheEtherSep 13, 2017GuruWhat makes it not mesh?