Orbi MR 2.1 issues update 3/9/18

I have been experimenting with a velop. So far all is working properly and I do connect to the closest node. I did notice this did take some time for this to work correctly. As the setup is all done wireless and after I moved to the correct place in my house and used wired connections. I had to renew connections from some devices to get them to switch to the closet node. Not sure if swicth while roaming i will have to test that later. But I have not noticed any problems from where devices are. There is not much roaming from room to room. 

But I really hope that netgear is close to a solution for the orbi. i do have a long return policy as i got directly from linksys. Hmm that return policy is as long as netgear gives for tech support. maybe netgear should look into customer safisfaction. As I am not satified that my orbi does not work right. 

So it looks like Velop is an inferior product after all.

I have had no major issues, except for one minor problem - satellite having lots of active network sessions (3198/65536) even if unused - visible on satellite debug page. I reported that. But it does not affect stability in any way.

---

wildhorsewrote:

So it looks like Velop is an inferior product after all.

 

I have had no major issues, except for one minor problem - satellite having lots of active network sessions (3198/65536) even if unused - visible on satellite debug page. I reported that. But it does not affect stability in any way.

---

Well i have not had an issue since i started testing a velop. I have not dropped my connection at all. I have a wired backhaul. this is not possible now with a orbi.

I would really like orbi to be working properly but if i try and user it i get aboyut 10 minutes before the internet connection drops. So to me right now the orbi is inferior. And the tech support at netgear does not know how to fix it. How mant months has this been going on now. They should have left it all back on the first firmware. It at least worked then.

Strange how they can get the orbi pro working but not this one. 

---

Starbuckywrote:

Good day DerAusgewandert,

 

I totally agree. I did some thorough testing with one satellite to compare to the Orbi and then added the second Velop satellite last night in our upstairs hallway. Adding the second satellite took over an hour, it just wouldn't complete sinking and kept telling me to bring it closer to the router... I ended up having to basically put it right next to the router..................... All said, in my case the RBK50 2pk is much better than Velop 3pk. I'm packing up the Velop tonight and re-installing the Orbi, keeping my fingers crossed that I continue to have minimal issues.

 

Cheers,

     

 

---

I gave the Velop another chance all day today and let it "work itself in". It didn't change/improve. Maybe I got a bad unit, but looking at posts like yours and the posts on the Linksys forum, this seems to be a more common problem. I am packing it up as I type and it's going back tomorrow. I have the Orbi back on and in my environment the Velop is simply not working well.

Good day,

I could have given it a couple more days but I am pretty sure no amount of tweaking would make it as good as the Orbi. The 3pk Velop didn't provide the performance compared to the 2pk Orbi. That's in my case/setup anyway. I'm sure others have different experiences. Anyway I packed up the Velop and Circle and will return them on the way home from work. As I sit at work my remote access to all my gizmos at home is rock solid again...

I'm not dismissing the big issues other longer term users are having though, I'm still worried and I hope NG resolves them before I start experiencing issues too. I'd really like to start using wired backhaul too. That said I, I've been waiting for more than a year to get a mesh consumer setup and from what I see with all the different manufacturers is that no one has a mature product without issues. They all suck to a certain extent. It should only get better....Maybe I should have waited another year. lol.       

Did you test the wired back haul while using the current version of FW? I though this version supported wired back haul.

https://community.netgear.com/t5/Orbi/How-do-i-setup-wired-backhaul-on-the-satellite-RBK40/m-p/1530387/highlight/false#M25944

---

Starbuckywrote:

Good day,

 

I could have given it a couple more days but I am pretty sure no amount of tweaking would make it as good as the Orbi. The 3pk Velop didn't provide the performance compared to the 2pk Orbi. That's in my case/setup anyway. I'm sure others have different experiences. Anyway I packed up the Velop and Circle and will return them on the way home from work. As I sit at work my remote access to all my gizmos at home is rock solid again...

 

I'm not dismissing the big issues other longer term users are having though, I'm still worried and I hope NG resolves them before I start experiencing issues too. I'd really like to start using wired backhaul too. That said I, I've been waiting for more than a year to get a mesh consumer setup and from what I see with all the different manufacturers is that no one has a mature product without issues. They all suck to a certain extent. It should only get better....Maybe I should have waited another year. lol.       

---

No FURRYe38 I haven't because I thought that wired backhaul was one of the issues why they pulled v.2.1.2.18. I loaded this firmware also because I wanted better parental control for my tecno addict children. I've had the Orbi for just over three weks now on wireless backhaul but I think.I might want to move the satellite a little further away and use wired backhaul. At the moment though I'm just happy that thesystem is stable so although I'm itching to play around with config I think I'll wait until the next release before I start tweaking/experimenting. Speaking of firmware I was asked if I wanted to join the beta testers and I accepted and then all comms went dark and I haven't heard back.               

Well something you can try. You can always disconnect the LAN cable if it doesn't work. 

You might make contact again and see if beta can be made available to you. 

---

Starbuckywrote:

No FURRYe38 I haven't because I thought that wired backhaul was one of the issues why they pulled v.2.1.2.18. I loaded this firmware also because I wanted better parental control for my tecno addict children. I've had the Orbi for just over three weks now on wireless backhaul but I think.I might want to move the satellite a little further away and use wired backhaul. At the moment though I'm just happy that thesystem is stable so although I'm itching to play around with config I think I'll wait until the next release before I start tweaking/experimenting. Speaking of firmware I was asked if I wanted to join the beta testers and I accepted and then all comms went dark and I haven't heard back.               

---

Ya actually I will try it, I want to test moving my satellite a little further anyway and wireless backhaul would probably suffer. I guess if I try wired backhaul and it messes things up which aren't reversed when I revert back to wireless backhaul I can reset Orbi and re-load saved config.

There ya go. 

What is the current distance between the router and Satellite. Mines about 40 feet. Not sure how much farther I can go in range. Mines currently on wired back haul.

Let us know how it turns out. 

Mine is more than 40feet. 45feet is the projection and then it's an additional 10 feet in the vertical because the satellite sits in the hallway of the second floor. There is a wall and a stairwell and ceiling in between. I had concerns when setting this up initially, but so far I have had no problems at all. Excellent signal throughout the house. I'm not using wired backhaul.

So are you saying that at 40 feet you could still use the wireless backhaul and get acceptable performance?

My satellite is under 30 feet away but the signal goes through three sets of walls (framed/drywall).

So you are using 2.1.2.18 with wired backhaul?     

---

Starbuckywrote:

So are you saying that at 40 feet you could still use the wireless backhaul and get acceptable performance?

My satellite is under 30 feet away but the signal goes through three sets of walls (framed/drywall).

So you are using 2.1.2.18 with wired backhaul?     

---

yep, v2.1.2.18. NO wired backhaul. No problems with performance so far. It's cool to see when I walk up the stairs and my phone switches over to the Satellite without a problem, while the signal stays on excellent. None of the clients on my 2nd floor have issues with connectivity. The main Orbi router has no problems covering the entire downstairs level, even though it's located at one long end of the house. My house is a little less than 4000sqf.

One nice side effect of the good connection is that response of my Philips Hue lights to Alexa commands is almost instant, while it often took seconds.

Anyone experiencing with wired backhaul in AP mode? 

Anyone experiencing issues with wired backhaul in AP mode? 

Yes! Connected devices would drop and not reconect. No bueno....

I dealt with the issues for over a year. Thank god I purchsed from Costco and they took it back. Went to an eero pro system connected to ethernet and guess what? No more issues. Getting between 350 and 400 Mbps to each client wirelessly. It just works! No more hearing screaming from my son and wife that the internet is down again. Guys, if they have not been able to make a stable router in over a year, they never will. Leave now while you still have your sanity