NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.

Forum Discussion

ChadHadsell's avatar
ChadHadsell
Aspirant
Mar 09, 2022

What is the limiting factor for the number of connected devices?

I have an RBR750 with two satellites. Currently I have about 50 total devices connected (phones, computers, printers, TVs, IoT devices, etc.... It all adds up fast!) and I'm noticing that some of the IoT devices in particular keep experiencing dropped connections to the router. The drops don't last long, and typically don't impact actual use.... yet. But I'm worried about future-proofing in case I want to install more smart lights, etc.
I noticed that Netgear advertises the RBR750 as being able to handle around 40 devices. I didnt think it would be an issue, since most of these devices use very little bandwidth, and get used relatively infrequently. But the drops are annoying and I an wondering if it has something to do with having too many things connected.

My question comes down to this: What exactly is the bottleneck that limits the RBR750 to around 40 connected device?  Is it the Wifi radios? Is it inherent to the Wifi version (AX, AC, N, etc.)? Or is it something to do with the processing power of the router itself?

If it's the router's processor or memory, I'd be happy to set up my own custom higher-powered router and run the Orbi in AP mode. If it's something to do with the wifi type or the number of radios, etc...well, then I'll have to either upgrade the Orbi or cut back on my IoT devices.

7 Replies

  • Depends on whats all connected at once and where there all connected. If there all connected at the RBR and not the RBS then this could be a problem. 

     

    What Firmware version is currently loaded?
    What is the Mfr and model# of the Internet Service Providers modem/ONT the NG router is connected too?

     

    What is the size of your home? Sq Ft?
    What is the distance between the router and 📡 satellite(s)? 30 feet or more is recommended in between RBR and RBS📡 to begin with depending upon building materials when wirelessly connected.
    https://kb.netgear.com/31029/Where-should-I-place-my-Orbi-satellite 📡

     

    What channels are you using? Auto? Try Auto and 48 on 5Ghz. Or try setting manual channel 1, 6 or 11 on 2.4Ghz and 40 to 48 channel on 5Ghz.
    Any Wifi Neighbors near by? If so, how many?

    • ChadHadsell's avatar
      ChadHadsell
      Aspirant

      Current firmware is V4.6.5.14_2.0.54

       

      ISP modem/router/ONT is a Zyxel c3000z in bridge mode.

      My house is about 2500 sq ft, but it's long and skinny with a giant brick fireplace/chimney structure in the middle that basically cuts the house in half.

       

      The RBR is at one end of the house. One RBS is two rooms away, about 50 feet from the router, next to the brick wall.  The other RBS is another 30 feet beyond that, other side of the brick wall toward the other end of the house, and on a lower floor.

      The far-end RBS sometimes tries to connect to the RBR, but has "Poor" backhaul status when it does, because it's too far away and through the thick brick wall. Fortunatelty, it usually finds its way back into a daisychain configuration, connecting via the middle RBS.

       

      2.4GHz is set to channel 6, which I settled on after some exploring with a wifi scanner and trying a few different channels. It's probably no better than when it was set to "auto," but it's hard to tell. The devices that drop frequently are WiFi smart bulbs and a couple of plugs, all of which are 2.4Ghz only.

       

      5GHz is currently set to channel 48, but again, no definite difference from "auto".

       

      I also set the CTS/RTS threshold to 2307, per a recommendation I found elsewhere on this forum. But I doubt that actually has any impact.

       

      I can typically see about 8 other SSIDs on my wifi scanner, but they are mostly -80 to -90 dBm, so a bit weak to be causing major interference, I think? Two 2.4GHz SSIDs are visible with around -70 dBm, but those are on different channels, and are the reason I settled on channel 6 for my 2.4GHz radios.  

       


  • ChadHadsell wrote:

    ...

    I noticed that Netgear advertises the RBR750 as being able to handle around 40 devices.

    ...

    My question comes down to this: What exactly is the bottleneck that limits the RBR750 to around 40 connected device?


    Could you please post a link to this Netgear statement about "40 devices".  I could not find such a statement on the official Product Data Sheet.  What I did find is this statement:

    My ancient RBR50 is putting along just fine with over 40 devices (most of them are idle or are IoT 'gizmos'). If my old router can support over 40, surely "4X" means "more than 50+".

    Compare the processors:

    RBR50 - Qualcom IPQ4019, 4 ARM Cortex A7, Clock Speed 171MH, 2 spatial streams

    RBR750 - Qualcom IPQ8174, 4 ARM Cortex A53, Clock Speed: 1400MH

     

    It will be nearly impossible to connect more than one Class C subnet (255.255.255.0) of devices, which  amounts to about 253, including the router, satellites, and user devices.  In practical terms, the "sky's the limit" on the 750 product line.  The WiFi radio spectrum will saturage before the router does.

     

    However (BIG drum roll), there are serious issues with connectivity in both the 750 and 850  product lines.  New firmware was officially released for the 850 last week and (I believe) there is a "pre-release" version for the 750 that is going around for those brave souls who are desperate.

     

     

    • ChadHadsell's avatar
      ChadHadsell
      Aspirant

      CrimpOn - The 40 device limit is on the main netgear home page, in the brief description of each current Orbi system. It's also on the specific product page, in the main product summary text: https://www.netgear.com/home/wifi/mesh/rbk753/

       

      With prior routers, I've always assumed the limit was available IP addresses on the subnet, like you said. But until a recent "smart home" buying spree, I'd never really had more than 30 or so devices regularly connected. So I figured maybe I missed something with regard to what WiFi can support, or what can reasonably be expected of residential routers with limited processors and memory.

      • CrimpOn's avatar
        CrimpOn
        Guru

        ChadHadsell wrote:

        CrimpOn - The 40 device limit is on the main netgear home page, in the brief description of each current Orbi system. It's also on the specific product page, in the main product summary text: https://www.netgear.com/home/wifi/mesh/rbk753/


        Absolutely correct, "for over 40 devices", plain as day.  More impressive than "over 20 devices", which one would think is also correct.

        Marketing literature is always amazing (to me).

         

        A couple of years ago, there was a post on the forum from someone who claimed to have over 120 devices on the original Orbi.  Surely the number of "devices" a WiFi system can accomodate must have some relationship to the usage these devices impose on the system and on the WiFi channel capacity.  100 smart plugs that together do not send 1mb of data a week is a lot different than 20 laptops playing World of Stupidity (or whatever).

         

        My money is still on the Orbi firmware issues, not the hardware.

    • atejwani's avatar
      atejwani
      Apprentice

      Hi CrimpOn, (and FURRYe38 , plemans )

       

      Could you please point me to the pre-release for the 750 series. 

       

      Thanks in Advance,

      Al

      CrimpOn wrote:

      ChadHadsell wrote:

      ...

      I noticed that Netgear advertises the RBR750 as being able to handle around 40 devices.

      ...

      My question comes down to this: What exactly is the bottleneck that limits the RBR750 to around 40 connected device?


      Could you please post a link to this Netgear statement about "40 devices".  I could not find such a statement on the official Product Data Sheet.  What I did find is this statement:

      My ancient RBR50 is putting along just fine with over 40 devices (most of them are idle or are IoT 'gizmos'). If my old router can support over 40, surely "4X" means "more than 50+".

      Compare the processors:

      RBR50 - Qualcom IPQ4019, 4 ARM Cortex A7, Clock Speed 171MH, 2 spatial streams

      RBR750 - Qualcom IPQ8174, 4 ARM Cortex A53, Clock Speed: 1400MH

       

      It will be nearly impossible to connect more than one Class C subnet (255.255.255.0) of devices, which  amounts to about 253, including the router, satellites, and user devices.  In practical terms, the "sky's the limit" on the 750 product line.  The WiFi radio spectrum will saturage before the router does.

       

      However (BIG drum roll), there are serious issues with connectivity in both the 750 and 850  product lines.  New firmware was officially released for the 850 last week and (I believe) there is a "pre-release" version for the 750 that is going around for those brave souls who are desperate.

       

       


       

      • ChadHadsell's avatar
        ChadHadsell
        Aspirant

        atejwani wrote:

        Could you please point me to the pre-release for the 750 series.  

         This is the one that I know of.  I haven't tried it since my issues aren't too bad, yet. I'm kind of hoping it or something newer comes out as an official release soon.  If not, or if my disconnections get worse, I may have to give it a go.