Nighthawk AC1900 EX7000 or Orbi in lath and plaster house

Question

I have a pretty typical scenero,a 1400 sq ft house, built in 1936, so lath and plaster walls throughout. Most of the living space is on 1 floor, but there is a room in the garage where we'd like to get WiFi, and possiby the back yard. The coax cable from my provider (Comcast) is in the front and back of the house with nothing in between. I also have CAT6 connecting the front and back. The main modem/router gateway is in the living room, and only coveres 1/2 the house due to the plaster walls (I get wifi 1/2 way down the block through the front window just fine). The devices connected are a two laptops, one printer, two TVs and three smart phones. We stream some movies, but not huge users of bandwidth.
&nbsp;
I was origininally going to just add a simple Nighthawk router in the back but realized I would end up with another network to connect to and maintain. The idea of the Orbi system sounded great, but&nbsp; a little expensive for us. Would the Nighthawk Mesh extender accomplish this? Seems like the same setup as the Orbi but much cheaper. What is the drawback?&nbsp;
This is the Mesh extender I'm looking at...
https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B00R92CLD6/ref=ox_sc_saved_title_1?smid=ATVPDKIKX0DER&amp;psc=1

apil1 · Answer

Orbi is a true peer-to-peer mesh where the satellites will daisy chain depending on what the strongest signal they can get is. Nighthawk is an add-on mesh component and is designed to prefer connecting directly to the router if it is within broadcast range even if another signal is stronger. If you are only adding a single extender this won't come into play. Nighthawk has more advanced user features than the Orbi. You may find a feature you want is not available on Orbi. If you want to create a One WiFi Name mesh network with a Nighthawk extender, make sure you are getting one that states mesh extender and not just range extender.

RobS10 · Answer

Anyone?

RobS10 · Answer

Thanks Apil1,
Just looking for an affordable way to get the whole house on one network, from living room to back of house, including garage (about 60 ft.). Will the Mesh extender do that? Do either the Mesh extender of Orbi still allow the Comcast Gateway router to work where it's the closest (best signal), or do they "take over" and become the router instead, and if so, do they work well enough through plater walls? I want to connect either drvice in the back bedroom and want to be sure I will still get strong WiFi in the front of the house (since the Comcast router can't cover that entire area due to the plaster walls).

apil1 · Answer

Both mesh extender and Orbi can work off a single WiFi name to extend the range of the signal further than the base reaches by itself. Mesh extender needs to select One WiFi Name mode or else it is in standard extender mode where it creates new wireless network ID instead.
&nbsp;
Mesh extender will add onto any standard wireless router to extend the signal from the router.
&nbsp;
Orbi would be a complete system replacement. If your ISP requires their router to support any of their services, you would have to change their router into bridge mode in order to connect the Orbi base. The Orbi base would take over as the router and WiFi, but the satellites work with the base to create the mesh network.
&nbsp;
With either mesh system, it's up to the client to decide which radio it wants to connect to and whether it properly roams between radios as the signal strength changes. Newer devices are more likely to support roaming than older ones. At minimum it will fill in deadspots with the extender or satellite placed between the device and the router for the device to connect to.

RobS10 · Answer

Would you say the EX7000 Mesh Extender, connected to the main Comcast Gateway via CAT6 cable, would be the best bet to "cover" my existing network (both the 2.4GHz and 5 GHz frequencies) in the back part of the house that the main Gateway can't reach? I believe the Comcast Gateway helps the main DVR in the living room communicate with the smaller cable box in the back bedroom for recorded programs, and maybe the Orbi taking over would cause problems unless I bought the really expensive Orbi that has a modem and phone built in?

Forum Discussion

Nighthawk AC1900 EX7000 or Orbi in lath and plaster house

8 Replies