WNR2000v2 port forwarding only forwards UDP

Thanks for the reply, and sorry for the delay as I wanted to actually try your suggestion.  But with holidays and traveling, pushed it off until I was home and I didn't want to answer "Did you do everything else right?" the way the average internet person would.  But they were entered correctly, just wasn't accepting the change. 

One odd thing I noticed later, is it could be set to TCP or UDP, just not TCP/UDP.  Which would have been a temporary viable work around.

Thanks for suggesting rolling back the firmware.  The hardware I work on actually can not go backwards, so I completely forgot about this as an option. 

I rolled back to version WNR2000v2_V1.2.0.6_36.0.58NA and everything just magically worked.  I could edit the old rules to be TCP/UDP, save and they properly got forwarded.  And fortunately all the settings were preserved.