NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.
Forum Discussion
6.6.1 Scrub Hammers CPU
And when I say hammers, I mean it runs with -1 prio and causes 6-8 kernel worker threads each vying to consume 100% of CPU. So rabid is this consumption that all other background processes, including...
We experience the "bad neighbor" scrub behavior too - I don't dare schedule a scrub during business hours: the responsiveness of the ReadyNAS over SMB suffers pretty severely. CPU load average 2.5-3 during a scrub on a ReadyNAS 516. OS 6.7.1, have never used the antivirus feature.
Can this be tamed down?
Exactly! It'd be great to be able to throttle the scrub somehow. Maybe a selectable priority, or limit it to a single thread/core.
Well this is confirmed to still be happening in 6.7.1. I observe that overall I/O and wait time seem OK. Indeed the journal entries that pop up as the job starts suggest it's throttling on I/O rate. However the kernel worker processes still monopolize the CPU cores/threads. A certain amount of application CPU usage seems OK, but if you have anything like PLEX transcribes or AFS based Time Machine, which cause a fair amount of CPU activity themselves, then these other processes get starved to the point of being almost unusable.
Some of this is just Btrfs behavior, which I can compare to similar operations I do on even newer kernels on other Linux machines. But when you have a server environment where there is an expectation of responsiveness from applications, it can be problematic. On this front, the only thing I would consider a standard OS issue is Time Machine backups. These are CPU intensive and will be seriously delayed if not fail outright -- based on previous painful experiences. In this run I'm not allowing TM to even trigger until the scrub finishes. I know for a fact I'll wind up having to trash my whole backup archive if I let it try and fail.
As for PLEX, I can work around the issue by enabling direct play and disabling transcode in the client config. But hopefully we get to a point where scrubs will gracefully butt out when other activity requires CPU attention.
That's unfortunate to hear. I was hoping that it would be somewhat better. I think it's going on day four for my scrub at about 90% complete now.
Are you using compression on any of your volumes/shares?I am running compression on one of my shares. I think I'll copy that data off to a new uncompressed share. I'll run another scrub to see what happens.
NETGEAR Academy
Boost your skills with the Netgear Academy - Get trained, certified and stay ahead with the latest Netgear technology!
Join Us!
