This topic has been marked solved and closed to new posts due to inactivity. We hope you'll join the conversation by posting to an open topic or starting a new one.
At the moment I have 2 Lan Cables coming from the bedroom / Office to the living room and as to avoid laying down a 3rd cable I was considering a switch at both ends to carry both USB and video.
I already have the GSS108E in the living room and was hoping that by adding a 2nd in the bedroom It may be possible to achieve the desired result. I have contacted the manufacturer and they claim that (at least the) HDMI extender will NOT work via a switch.
However if I were to setup VLAN tagging on both swiches, would it work? Note I have no experience of VLAN Tagging. So any advice on how to set this up would also be appreciated.
Re: HDMI Over Ethernet With Netgear GSS108E & VLAN Tagging
Happy to help and I just realized I didn't look up your USB Extender. It turns out this USB kit is NOT IP, it speaks again another (proprietary) language and it's not meant to leverage an Ethernet network. So you're back to:
- The HDBase-T kit that you have selected will use its own, dedicated LAN cable. You must have one independent CAT5e, CAT6 or better LAN cable available between your PC and your TV. In fact, the HDBase-T transmitter (PC side) will send the video from your PC to the HDBase-T receiver (TV side) using a LAN cable in between. This LAN cable cannot go through a switch or anything else, it must be entirely dedicated and straight between the Tx and the Rx.
- The USB kit that you have selected will use its own, dedicated LAN cable. You must have one independent CAT5e, CAT6 or better LAN cable available between your PC and your TV. In fact, the USB transmitter (PC side) will send the USB signals from your PC to the USB receiver (TV side) using a LAN cable in between. This LAN cable cannot go through a switch or anything else, it must be entirely dedicated and straight between the Tx and the Rx. Again.
Net net: you must have two dedicated LAN cables available between your PC and your TV. I originally thought you selected USB-over-IP technology, but you did not.
At this stage, your Ethernet Switch location, usage, and availability don't matter because none of your Audio/Video/USB transport products are Ethernet-based. The title of your post should be understood as HDMI and USB over proprietary extenders because nothing here is actually over-IP.
VLAN is not the problem, you are procuring an HDBase-T extender that is NOT Ethernet-based, so it's not Video-over-IP. The manufacturer you have contacted is right, this "extender" speaks another language, it's not Ethernet, it's another signal - not IP. This HDBase-T extender will need a dedicated RJ45 (CAT-5e, CAT6 or better) cable between the transmitter and the receiver.
Three solutions:
1. You have one LAN cable available so you can use it with your HDBase-T kit, and you can leverage your Ethernet network over your other LAN cables for USB/KVM; this way the USB control would transit through your LAN network and the video would transit through your HDBase-T bridge
2. You don't have a LAN cable available, you can lay down a new LAN cable to achieve the solution 1/ above
3. You cancel your order for the HDBase-T kit and you select a standard Video-over-IP technology, based on 1Gbps (so with compression, H264 CODECs or other) or based on 10Gbps (SDVoE zero-frame latency) that will leverage true Ethernet instead. If you are in the UK, for instance, you can contact ZeeVee, AV Distribution manufacturer and great NETGEAR partner in the SDVoE Alliance. ZeeVee EMEA Sales Support number is actually in the UK. They sure could help you.
Re: HDMI Over Ethernet With Netgear GSS108E & VLAN Tagging
Happy to help and I just realized I didn't look up your USB Extender. It turns out this USB kit is NOT IP, it speaks again another (proprietary) language and it's not meant to leverage an Ethernet network. So you're back to:
- The HDBase-T kit that you have selected will use its own, dedicated LAN cable. You must have one independent CAT5e, CAT6 or better LAN cable available between your PC and your TV. In fact, the HDBase-T transmitter (PC side) will send the video from your PC to the HDBase-T receiver (TV side) using a LAN cable in between. This LAN cable cannot go through a switch or anything else, it must be entirely dedicated and straight between the Tx and the Rx.
- The USB kit that you have selected will use its own, dedicated LAN cable. You must have one independent CAT5e, CAT6 or better LAN cable available between your PC and your TV. In fact, the USB transmitter (PC side) will send the USB signals from your PC to the USB receiver (TV side) using a LAN cable in between. This LAN cable cannot go through a switch or anything else, it must be entirely dedicated and straight between the Tx and the Rx. Again.
Net net: you must have two dedicated LAN cables available between your PC and your TV. I originally thought you selected USB-over-IP technology, but you did not.
At this stage, your Ethernet Switch location, usage, and availability don't matter because none of your Audio/Video/USB transport products are Ethernet-based. The title of your post should be understood as HDMI and USB over proprietary extenders because nothing here is actually over-IP.
