This topic has been marked solved and closed to new posts due to inactivity. We hope you'll join the conversation by posting to an open topic or starting a new one.
I have a new-to-me RN526x, which has 2x10G copper ethernet ports. Currently, it is connected to a Netgear GS108E switch (1 Gigabit x 8 ports). I would like to update the network with a 10G switch and 10G ethernet cards in two main computers. The situation is domestic offices, Windows 10, Cat 6 cabling, RNAS OS6.10.4. Noise level under 25dB is needed.
I also have an older RNAS (ProPioneer, updated to OS6.10) that will be used as a backup for the RN526. It is limited to 2 x 1G ethernet ports. It can be connected to the updated 10G switch in a LAG arrangement.
An 8-port 10G switch would serve the RNAS 526 (1 or 2 ports), main computers (2 ports total), the older RNAS (2 ports for the LAG), an uplink port to an additional 1G switch and leave one open port.
Budget under US$1,000.
Netgear XS708E or XS708T seem to fit. The XS708E is criticized for loud fan noise on Amazon. Other than that, I do not understand the difference between these 2 product offerings. If forum members could point out other products I should consider, that would be great.
Good to know. What is your subjective impression of the noise from the fans?
The switch is in the basement, and is co-located with other equipment (several ReadyNAS and a PoE switch). So I don't think a sound measurement (or a subjective impression) would give you any good information, given the mix of equipment.
Acoustic noise is spec'd at 36.7 dba @ 25C on the datasheet (the XS716E is a bit quieter, at 33.9 dba).
XS708E is an "enhanced" switch, meaning it has some configuration options. However, the XS708T is a Smart switch and has a lot more features. I would pick the XS708T, personally - if price difference isn't too big.
I would however advise you visit the forums for Netgear switches and pose the question there. Both these switches are "older" models that have been out for a good few years now. There might be other options worth looking at.
FWIW, I am using an XS708Ev2, and it is working well.
Though if you need more than 8 ports total, then your expected usage does play into this decision. You might want a switch that has more ports (some gigabit, others 10 gigabit).
Also, if you get a multigig switch, make sure you can set the speed manually on the switch port. The RN526 doesn't do multigig negotiation.
Good to know. What is your subjective impression of the noise from the fans? If you have a smart phone sound level app, would you take a measurement at, say 25 cm (10")?
Good to know. What is your subjective impression of the noise from the fans?
The switch is in the basement, and is co-located with other equipment (several ReadyNAS and a PoE switch). So I don't think a sound measurement (or a subjective impression) would give you any good information, given the mix of equipment.
Acoustic noise is spec'd at 36.7 dba @ 25C on the datasheet (the XS716E is a bit quieter, at 33.9 dba).
