Reply
Topic Options
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Float this Topic for Current User
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Printer Friendly Page
ReadyDLNA 1.1.2.3 solved my albumartist problems, but ...
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Inappropriate Content
2014-08-28
03:59 PM
2014-08-28
03:59 PM
ReadyDLNA 1.1.2.3 solved my albumartist problems, but ...
There are several threads in this forum describing the problems ReadyDLNA has with meta data for compilations ("Various Artists"); see e.g. http://www.readynas.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=76&t=34169. My most important UPnP client, the Raumfeld Connector 2, doesn't understand the meta data that the stock ReadyDLNA server in RAIDiator 4.2.26 provides for compilations. When a compilation has 20 songs by different artists, the album will show up 20 times, each with a single song. This can get annoying with a large collection - the list of albums is unneccessarily inflated. Moreover, the songs of the album can't be played in sequence without creating a playlist.
Fortunately, the update of ReadyDLNA 1.1.2.3 (http://www.readynas.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=76&t=27946) solved this problem for me.
It's still not perfect, though - now my clients will not display the song artist any more at all. This applies to both Raumfeld and BubbleUPnP.
Maybe an example makes it clear. The following vorbis comments in my FLAC file were set using MusicBrainz Picard. Only the relevant parts here:
Stock RAIDiator 4.2.26 ReadyDLNA converts this to the following XML, which breaks the "Albums" virtual folder (note that "Various Artists" appears nowhere in the meta data any more):
Note that both <dc:creator> and <upnp:artist> are set to the "artist" tag from the music file.
ReadyDLNA 1.1.2.3 (and minidlna 1.1.3) come up with the following, improved scheme:
Here <upnp:artist> is changed to the albumartist tag, which works better - all I am missing is now the information about the artist e.g. in the BubbleUPnP "Now Playing" screen.
TwonkyMedia uses <upnp:albumArtist>, which works best with my clients:
Another improvement of ReadyDLNA 1.1.2.3 above the stock version (and Twonky, I should add) is that it sets the <dc:creator> and <upnp:artist> tags of the album itself (folder, "container") to "Various Artists". The other servers, for some unkown reason, set it to the artist of the first song in the album, which is highly irritating.
The bottom line is: ReadyDLNA/minidlna should make use of <upnp:albumArtist>.
Fortunately, the update of ReadyDLNA 1.1.2.3 (http://www.readynas.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=76&t=27946) solved this problem for me.
It's still not perfect, though - now my clients will not display the song artist any more at all. This applies to both Raumfeld and BubbleUPnP.
Maybe an example makes it clear. The following vorbis comments in my FLAC file were set using MusicBrainz Picard. Only the relevant parts here:
title=Berimbeau
albumartist=Various Artists
album=Diggin' Deeper 2: The Roots of Acid Jazz
compilation=1
artist=Os Ipanemas
Stock RAIDiator 4.2.26 ReadyDLNA converts this to the following XML, which breaks the "Albums" virtual folder (note that "Various Artists" appears nowhere in the meta data any more):
<item id="1$7$0$0" parentID="1$7$0" ...>
<dc:title>Berimbau</dc:title>
<upnp:album>Diggin' Deeper 2: The Roots of Acid Jazz</upnp:album>
<dc:creator>Os Ipanemas</dc:creator>
<upnp:artist>Os Ipanemas</upnp:artist>
...
Note that both <dc:creator> and <upnp:artist> are set to the "artist" tag from the music file.
ReadyDLNA 1.1.2.3 (and minidlna 1.1.3) come up with the following, improved scheme:
<item id="1$7$0$0" parentID="1$7$0" ...>
<dc:title>Berimbau</dc:title>
<upnp:album>Diggin' Deeper 2: The Roots of Acid Jazz</upnp:album>
<dc:creator>Os Ipanemas</dc:creator>
<upnp:artist>Various Artists</upnp:artist>
...
Here <upnp:artist> is changed to the albumartist tag, which works better - all I am missing is now the information about the artist e.g. in the BubbleUPnP "Now Playing" screen.
TwonkyMedia uses <upnp:albumArtist>, which works best with my clients:
<item id="0$1$12$609R5538314" refID="0$1$8I5538314" ...>
<dc:title>Berimbau</dc:title>
<upnp:album>Diggin' Deeper 2: The Roots of Acid Jazz</upnp:album>
<dc:creator>Os Ipanemas</dc:creator>
<upnp:artist>Os Ipanemas</upnp:artist>
<upnp:albumArtist>Various Artists</upnp:albumArtist>
...
Another improvement of ReadyDLNA 1.1.2.3 above the stock version (and Twonky, I should add) is that it sets the <dc:creator> and <upnp:artist> tags of the album itself (folder, "container") to "Various Artists". The other servers, for some unkown reason, set it to the artist of the first song in the album, which is highly irritating.
The bottom line is: ReadyDLNA/minidlna should make use of <upnp:albumArtist>.
Message 1 of 1
Labels: