NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.
Forum Discussion
semola1
Apr 21, 2020Tutor
RN102 - Disk Upgrade
Hi all, I need to upgrade my NAS changing the actually 2x4Tb disks with 2x6Tb or more. For changing disk can I change one drive at a time and wait for the realignment/rebuild of system? Than...
- May 08, 2020
Of corse. The fan has become noisy as a result of the numerous times that I have cleaned it from dust.
I will look for a fan with equal revolutions and, if possible, greater CFM
Thanks
StephenB
Apr 22, 2020Guru
semola1 wrote:
No problem.
I take this opportunity to ask for advice on the disc (obviously a couple) to buy: Western Digital WD101EFAX or Seagate ST10000VN0008? I didn't found a site that compares them. Looking at the datasheets they look the same, apart from the rotation speed: the WD is a 5400 RPM, the other is 7200. Which do you recommend?
thanks
Semola
Both are good choices. Generally speaking the WD Reds use less power and run cooler than the corresponding IronWolf drives. So I'd personally pick the Red drive.
semola1
May 08, 2020Tutor
Hi,
I have succesfully changed my NAS disks with 2 new WD101EFAX discs.
I noticed a considerable increase in the temperature of the disks and the CPU. I have changed the fan setting to increase the air flow, but it has become very noisy (I will also have to change the fan).
On this I have two things to ask you: what is the maximum acceptable temperature for the disks and the CPU?
Does anyone have the characteristics of the fan mounted as standard? I'd like to look for an equivalent.
Thanks
Semola
- StephenBMay 08, 2020Guru
semola1 wrote:
Hi,
I have succesfully changed my NAS disks with 2 new WD101EFAX discs.
I noticed a considerable increase in the temperature of the disks and the CPU. I have changed the fan setting to increase the air flow, but it has become very noisy (I will also have to change the fan).
On this I have two things to ask you: what is the maximum acceptable temperature for the disks and the CPU?
Does anyone have the characteristics of the fan mounted as standard? I'd like to look for an equivalent.
ThanksSemola
WD specs the operating range of the WD101EFAX as 0-65C here: https://documents.westerndigital.com/content/dam/doc-library/en_us/assets/public/western-digital/product/internal-drives/wd-red-hdd/data-sheet-western-digital-wd-red-hdd-2879-800002.pdf
The datasheet of the Armada 370 CPU is surprisingly hard to find, but there is a copy here: http://dtsheet.com/doc/1285717/armada-370-hardware-specifications. The operating range of the CPU (Tj) is 0 to 105C.
FWIW, current thinking on disk reliability is that relative humidity is a more important factor than temperature. Though I wouldn't want my disks to run anywhere close to 65C myself. One disadvantage of the newer WD101EFAX is that it uses more power than the WD100EFAX (and therefore will run hotter than the older model).
The WD disks (including two WD100EFAX) in my main NAS run between 31-36C. Though there are several posts here from folks who's disks are running in the mid 50s. Most are using Seagate drives (which in my experience often do run hotter). But WD101EFAX operating power (8.4 watts) could bring the temps up into that range.
As far as the fan goes, I think the best path is to find the fan model google for it's specs. I'm not seeing any posts here from anyone who replaced it.
- SandsharkMay 08, 2020Sensei
If you replace the fan, be sure you get one with similar RPM and CFM ratings. Of course, that typically means that it's going to be about as noisy as the original unless there is something actually wrong with yours.
- semola1May 08, 2020Tutor
Of corse. The fan has become noisy as a result of the numerous times that I have cleaned it from dust.
I will look for a fan with equal revolutions and, if possible, greater CFM
Thanks
- SandsharkMay 08, 2020Sensei
If you clean the fan with compressed air, you should use something to keep it from spinning. Otherwise, the bearings can be damaged. I don't think the stock fan has ball bearings, so you might also look for that, if you can find them in an otherwise compatible fan.
Related Content
NETGEAR Academy

Boost your skills with the Netgear Academy - Get trained, certified and stay ahead with the latest Netgear technology!
Join Us!