PS4 connect to Orbi (get IP) but won't connect to Internet

Router Firmware Version  V2.3.5.30, That seems to be the latest available.

The good news is I finally figured it out. For whatever reason, the mac of the PS4 was getting blocked from the list of attached Devices.   The browser interface from Basic > Attached Devices was not refreshing nor reflecting the actual status.  It did show all devices as Allowed.

I got an old PS3 that I never connected to this router and wanted to see if there was a weird setting I was missing (on the PS).  When I connected that PS3, at that point I saw a blocked device flashed red at the top of the list but the label showed as an iPad.  When I refreshed the screen I didn't see it anymore (either the device or the blocked status), everything GREEN.

Went to Advanced > Security> Access Control and there I saw the PS4 mac address listed blocked. I selected the device, hit ALLOW and problem solved.  That simple!    ...but, is it really solved?

In the process of doing problem determination, I uninstalled Parental Control and Circle.  I wonder if that might have blocked the device and left it in that state when I uninstalled them.

In any case, the Attached Devices screen never showed me the device as blocked. I would get an IP when I connected the PS4 via wifi and eth so I didn't think the device would be blocked.  I was also trying to troubleshoot from the phone app, the Device Manager there didn't show the PS4 blocked.    It was by chance, connecting a new device that refreshed for a moment the Attached Devices screen and pointed me to the issue.

Last bit of info that still confuses me.  I would have 2 mac addresses for the PS4, one eth and one wifi.   When I went into Advanced > Security> Access Control, I only allowed the wifi mac address but after that, the eth started to work as well.   Shouldn't the eth still be blocked?