Issue with 2nd VLAN

Hello All,

I am having an issue where I have 2 VLANs setup on a GS728TX but when plugged into the second VLAN I cannot access the computers on that VLAN. (IP scheme and subnets are the same).

I have 2 computers with 2 NIC's each on different subnets (Computer 1: 192.168.1.70 and 192.168.2.70; Computer 2: 192.168.1.71 and 192.168.2.71). I have 192.168.1 on VLAN 2 (our Local network) and 192.168.2 on VLAN 1 (our default). The screen shots below are how the VLANs are assigned on the switch. If i plug into one of the untagged ports on VLAN 2 and ping 192.168.1.70, which is also plugged into one of these untagged ports, I get nothing (request timed out/unreachable). Is there something I am doing wrong? Is there a setting I forgot or need to do to allow access? I have a router plugged into the tagged port on VLAN 1 to communicate between VLANs (or so I thought ha)

Thank you so much in advance!