NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.

Forum Discussion

steveoelliott's avatar
May 16, 2016
Solved

ReadyNAS 516 / OS6 dual redundancy with X-RAID2

Hi,

 

I've been looking into this and been unable to find a definitive answer... If I were to setup a new ReadyNAS 516 with 4 freshly installed disks, would I be able to configure X-RAID2 in dual redundancy mode like I could on the old Pro 6 under 4.2?

 

It seems that I may have to first convert it to Flex-Raid level 6 and then back to X-RAID2.

 

This would seem a little cumbersome if starting out with 4 drives.

 

Thanks...


  • steveoelliott wrote:

     

     

    It seems that I may have to first convert it to Flex-Raid level 6 and then back to X-RAID2.

     


    With OS4, converting to flexraid required a factory reset.  That's not the case with OS 6.

     

    If you are starting fresh, then you start with 3 disks, change to flexraid and add the fourth for redundancy, then switch back.  It isn't intuitive, but isn't difficult either.

     

    Alternatively, you can insert all four, switch to flexraid while the volume is building/syncing.  You can then destroy it (while it is building) and recreate it as RAID-6.

     

     

16 Replies

Replies have been turned off for this discussion
  • Retired_Member's avatar
    Retired_Member

    Hi steveoelliott,

     

    I have replied to this here:

    https://community.netgear.com/t5/Using-your-ReadyNAS/XRAID-turned-RAID5-into-RAID6-when-adding-a-drive/m-p/1082474#M108821

     

    "X-RAID doesn't treat 6 HDDs the same way depending on the number of bays. So it changes a little bit the scenarios.

    If the chassis has 6 bays or less, it won't go to RAID6. If the chassis has more than 6 bays, it goes to RAID6 starting at the sixth disk."

     

    So if you want a RAID6 on a RN516, you need to use Flex-RAID and manually create the volume. RAID6 on 4 HDDs is a good idea for redundancy, but it's certainly not the best "default" option that should chosen in every situation where there are 4 HDDs in a chassis, so it can't be X-RAID2's default behavior with 4 HDDs.

    I don't understand why you qualify this of "cumbersome", please explain.

  • StephenB's avatar
    StephenB
    Guru - Experienced User

    steveoelliott wrote:

     

     

    It seems that I may have to first convert it to Flex-Raid level 6 and then back to X-RAID2.

     


    With OS4, converting to flexraid required a factory reset.  That's not the case with OS 6.

     

    If you are starting fresh, then you start with 3 disks, change to flexraid and add the fourth for redundancy, then switch back.  It isn't intuitive, but isn't difficult either.

     

    Alternatively, you can insert all four, switch to flexraid while the volume is building/syncing.  You can then destroy it (while it is building) and recreate it as RAID-6.

     

     

    • steveoelliott's avatar
      steveoelliott
      Luminary

      So it's not easy and intuitive like is was on OS 4.2

       

      To summarise, when loading or factory defaulting a new system with 4 disks, one should convert to flex-raid level 6 and then revert back to XRAID-2 to benefit from dual redundancy over the 4 disks.

       

      Thanks...

      • StephenB's avatar
        StephenB
        Guru - Experienced User

        steveoelliott wrote:

        To summarise, when loading or factory defaulting a new system with 4 disks, one should convert to flex-raid level 6 and then revert back to XRAID-2 to benefit from dual redundancy over the 4 disks.

         


        Yes.

         

NETGEAR Academy

Boost your skills with the Netgear Academy - Get trained, certified and stay ahead with the latest Netgear technology! 

Join Us!

ProSupport for Business

Comprehensive support plans for maximum network uptime and business peace of mind.

 

Learn More