NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.
Forum Discussion
Western Digital White Label Drives In ReadyNAS
I have many ReadyNAS units and always used Western Digital 3TB and 4TB Red drives. I have a new project where I need a ton of storage and need to splurge on about ten 8TB drives.
I see that people are shucking external drives to find White Label drives that are very similar to Reds except for two things.
1. You have to cover the 3rd 3.3v pin with Kapton tape so it will turn on.
2. You have to enable TLER since it is not enabled on the White Label drives (It is on the Reds). I know you can set the TLER but apparently, it will lose that setting on power down...
I was looking at WD80EZAZ White Label drives, but dont want to buy anything is I am going to run into issues down the road...
Has anyone ever used these drives in their setup?
7 Replies
Replies have been turned off for this discussion
I am not aware of any ReadyNAS that includes the 3.3V on the SATA interface, those pins are just open; so taping over the power enable pin should not be necessary. The Pro6 definately does not.
Since Netgear includes some drives that do not support TLER on their compatibility list, I'm not sure why you believe enabling it is a must. Here is an interesting article on the subject: Should-you-use-tler-drives-in-your-raid-nas .
So what Im reading is this:
"The responses I received from Synology, QNAP, NETGEAR and Buffalo all indicated that their NAS RAID controllers don't depend on or even listen to TLER, CCTL, ERC or any other similar error recovery signal from their drives. Instead, their software RAID controllers have their own criteria for drive timeouts, retries and when a drive is finally marked bad."
If this is true, then having drives with TLER in not needed because OS6 handles things its own way, correct?
"So investing in these more expensive drives is probably a smart move if your NAS is under constant heavy use. But it will be the more robust drive construction and not TLER / CCTL / ERC that will make your RAID NAS more reliable."
The WD White Label drives are some of the better drives they are talking about correct?
According to this link they are actually all HGST Helium Enterprise drives which is also good, correct?
Would you use White Label drives in your setup?
egranuloma wrote:
The WD White Label drives are some of the better drives they are talking about correct?
According to this link they are actually all HGST Helium Enterprise drives which is also good, correct?
Would you use White Label drives in your setup?
Other links I've seen say they are white-labeled WD Reds. So WD might relabel a variety of drives (perhaps depending on inventory). Reds make more sense to me though, since power and heat are factors with USB drives, and 5400 rpm models would use less power and run a lot cooler.
I've never used one myself (though I've sometimes been tempted to try one in my backup NAS). There are folks who've posted here saying that they used the drives successfully.
One factor is that you do give up the warranty (and the ability to return to the seller) as soon as you shuck the drives.
NETGEAR Academy
Boost your skills with the Netgear Academy - Get trained, certified and stay ahead with the latest Netgear technology!
Join Us!
