NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.
Forum Discussion
X-Raid or Raid-5
I am resurrecting an old NV+ V1, with four 2TB drives. Since I can never expand beyond this, it seems there's no benefit in X-Raid flexibility. Should I let it use X-Raid by default, or choose Flex...
pourpain wrote:
Since I can never expand beyond this, it seems there's no benefit in X-Raid flexibility. Should I let it use X-Raid by default, or choose Flex Raid-5?
It doesn't matter, as the underlying RAID mode will be identical. XRAID is easier to set up (no need to over-ride the RAID mode via RAIDar), so you might as well just use that.
Thank you. I have read in a few places (unofficial, not in the documentation) that X-Raid uses Raid 4. They also say that it is slightly better for sequential reads. I assume in practice it might not matter (this unit is not fast enough to make any difference?).
pourpain wrote:
Thank you. I have read in a few places (unofficial, not in the documentation) that X-Raid uses Raid 4. They also say that it is slightly better for sequential reads. I assume in practice it might not matter (this unit is not fast enough to make any difference?).
The v1 ReadyNAS (sparc-processor systems) all use a dedicated parity disk - which is technically RAID-4. But it's labeled as RAID-5 in FlexRAID. So the on-disk structures are exactly the same.
Newer ReadyNAS systems (4.2.x, 5.3.x, 6.x) all distribute the parity blocks across the drives in the array (which is normal RAID-5).
As far as performance goes, RAID-5 distributes writes evenly across the disks. With RAID-4, the partity disk needs to be updated for every write. That increases wear on that disk, and also can become a performance bottleneck. Though with the v1 NAS, the performance bottleneck is the CPU speed and memory in the NAS (not surprising in a 15-20 year old hardware design).
Thanks again. It is strange they would label it as Raid 5 when it is not. But in this case, like you said, X-Raid is easier so the default will work fine.
I received 3 additional drives today and plugged them in. It is syncing/building now, am considering a factory reset to hopefully speed that process up... How do I idenfify which disk it has picked to use for the dedicated partity device (under raid 4)?
pourpain wrote:
I received 3 additional drives today and plugged them in. It is syncing/building now, am considering a factory reset to hopefully speed that process up... How do I idenfify which disk it has picked to use for the dedicated partity device (under raid 4)?
Normally it would be the last disk in the array.
NETGEAR Academy
Boost your skills with the Netgear Academy - Get trained, certified and stay ahead with the latest Netgear technology!
Join Us!
