NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.

Forum Discussion

OrbiDemigod's avatar
OrbiDemigod
Apprentice
Dec 30, 2018
Solved

Firmware Update Nightmares - The Never Ending Saga...

It's been almost 1 year since my Orbi has been unplugged, serving as a $400 brick in the corner of my shelf, still staring at my Orbi everyday, as a reminder that this company wasted $400 (plus tax) of my hard earned money. Part of me wants to cry, and the other part of me silent, angered, betrayed a company could ever do this to its customers.

I have moved on to the Netgear XR500 Gaming Router ($300) the past year. A decision I don't regret as the brand is still Netgear.

Let the stories begin...

  • Ajzach's avatar
    Ajzach
    Jan 03, 2019

    Thanks a lot ...I did as suggested and problem solved

19 Replies

  • FURRYe38's avatar
    FURRYe38
    Guru - Experienced User

    Have you tried the manual FW file load on your system and then factory reset and setup from scratch? 

    Others reported this method worked for them.

    https://community.netgear.com/t5/Orbi/Firmware-2-2-1-210-released-as-of-10-3-18/m-p/1647303/highlight/true#M42416

     

    I always use this method on my Orbi and NG routers. Even after autoupdating. 

    I believe the problem is in the autoupdate process and how that system applies FW to users systems. Just doesn't seem to do a correct application of FW that allows the user to continue using the router and causes problems soon after it's applied or breaks something internally. Seen this with my system in beta testing. After doing a FW re-load manully AND a reset and setup from scratch, the system works as expected. Aside of oddities of Access Controls not working, and Daisy Chain seem to be broke or working in reverse on v210, it's overall working. 

     

    Have you asked about an RMA? 

    • Ragar99's avatar
      Ragar99
      Luminary

      To answer you question all Netgear has done is slow down the delivery of firmware updates which does reduce misery given their spiffy auto update feature. 

       

      My suggestion is use Orbi's in AP mode only, I've only had one issue since going to AP mode shortly after purchase a year+ ago.  That is what these things are good for...wifi, so AP mode and pair with a good router is the way to go.

    • JoeCymru's avatar
      JoeCymru
      Virtuoso

      Coming here, I have often wondered what percentage of the Orbi installed base are represented. Looking at Amazon and Best Buy, there seems to be a lot of content people, and looking at tech mag reviews Orbi is always up there. I have had my Orbi system for over a year. Netgear modem, Orbi set in router mode. Through all the firmware updates I have had exactly two events: One satellite disconnected and was stubborn in reconnection, but with a bit of manipulation came back on line and continued to perform just fine. The other event was daisy chain doing wierd stuff. After figuring out what that was all about and doing a work around, everything came back great. Currently I have 28 devices hooked up to Orbi, and over Christmas with hosting a house full, there were 40. No one complained and everyone was able to do what they wanted to do on line in every corner of the house, without affecting my home devices operations at all. My house is about 2600 sq. ft. and people were doing their facetime out in the detached pergula, or in front looking at a guest's new truck and googling to see if he really got a good deal.

      Just saying. For everyone who needs to tell about looking at a brick for a year, despising the choice they made, there are countless others who have had a year or more worth of experience, shaky firmware updates and all, of getting their money's worth. I bought Orbi for coverage with performance (believe me, it is not the most unobtrusive design out there but it does have big antennas). I retired my trusty RT-ac68U and Netgear extender and instead of having 5GHz fall off the clifff with distance from the old trusty Asus (and extender signals are sucky at best), have the available wifi connections I need with signal strengths that never drop below -50 db, and run -30 to -40 db at ten feet from router and each satellite. 

       

      • dorqus's avatar
        dorqus
        Guide

        FWIW I've had really no issues with the Orbi's (RBR50 and one RBS50) in router mode, connected to my Optimum cable modem (can't recall the brand, and I'm not in the same room as it is right now)   I'm using firmware 2.2.1.210.  Don't have a complex setup, not a huge house, router and satellite are connected wirelessly, I don't have ethernet anywhere in my house.
        So it's Optimum -> Cable Modem -> RBR50.
        I have a printer and Raspberry Pi connected to the satellite, everything else (a mix of iPhones, a few Android tablets/phones, X-Box 1, two "smart" TVs, a laptop, some chromebooks, Mac Mini are all connected wirelessly.  Since I installed the Orbi I've not had a single issue with Netflix on the smart TVs - previously with the Optimum branded D-Link router I'd have to power cycle the TV or the WiFi router to get Netflix to works.


        Your mileage may vary of course.

         

  • I recently installed an RBR50 with one Satellite; replacing my previous, two-year old R8500 Nighthawk. The Nighthawk lost connectivity to the Internet, but still would broadcast local Wifi (LAN). So, I thought this would be a good time to try something new (Mesh). So far, the experience has not been flawless, but overall, it has shown to be a good investment. I upgraded to the latest FW shortly after installing, manipulated a few configuration settings and have integrated my MOCA (TIVO) network with the new configuration. My experience has been good, although I lost my MOCA network for a period just before New Years and had to reconfigure. 

    Overall, I have no significant complaints, but do question why some confguration settings are offered (Implicit Beamforming, MU-MIMO, etc.) while others are not (QOS). I'm still testing some of the available features to determine if using any will make a performance differnce, but overall I I'm extermely satisfied with my decision to go this route. 

  • Hello Orbi Community Members,

     

    Happy New Year to all of you! I'd like to take an opportunity to chime in (if I may).

     

    OrbiDemigod - If you chose to give your Orbi WiFi System another try, I'd like to specifically address a possible issue with updating the firmware on an Orbi system that has been offline (unplugged) for an extended period of time. It is possible that the number of updates that have been provided during this period may not allow you to cleanly update to the current firmware version since there may be some dependencies that were introduced in a previous firmware version that has not yet been installed on your system.

     

    Please update the system to firmware version 2.1.4.16 prior to updating to the most recent version. 

     

    Here is a helpful article that provides instructions on how to manually update your system: How do I manually update the firmware on my Orbi WiFi System?

     

     Please note: if your system is not RBK50 please browse by product: Orbi - Browse by Model

    • There are two files you'll need to download. One for the Router (RBR50) and another for the Satellite (RBS50)
    • Once you have updated your system to firmware version 2.1.4.16 you should be able to use the automated process within the Orbi Admin Console to check/install updates. 

    I am happy to work with you directly if further assistance is needed. 

     

    Thank you one and all for your input on this topic!

     

    Best Regards,

    Christine 

     

    • Ajzach's avatar
      Ajzach
      Initiate

      '"Hi All

       

      I just bought a RBK50 AC 3000 and am struggling to update the firmware, first off I bought the product at a heavily discounted price here in the swiss market from a shop that was closing down, so the product was in their shelf for a long time. Thus te FW the RBK and RBS use as is default from the box is  V1.4.0.18 , and I am trying to update it to the latest.

      I read up the some prvious posts and thus tried to download the FW manually and then update the FW , but I keep getting "Please select correct configuration file" message and so am not able to upload the downloaded FW . What should I do? from my post it should be clear that I am a total noob at this, I was expectig an out of box and easy to setup/ pdate device...Please help

      • FURRYe38's avatar
        FURRYe38
        Guru - Experienced User

        You need to update the satellites first then the router. 

        You need to download an intermediate version of FW for both Satellites and router, lets try Version 2.0.0.74. Also download the recent v210 version as well for both. 

        https://www.netgear.com/support/product/RBK50.aspx#download

         

        Have the satellites connected to the router with the currnet version and send the intermediate version of FW to the satelites first. Then after those are updated, update the router. Once both are on the intermediate version, send the v210 to the satellites then send it to the router. Then you should be all caught up. I would do full factory reset after v210 is applied and set everythinng up from scratch. 

         

        After you set up the router and system, do a Backup of the router to file. Save this file for later use if you need to factory reset the router. Saves time on setup after the reset. 

         


        Ajzach wrote:

        '"Hi All

         

        I just bought a RBK50 AC 3000 and am struggling to update the firmware, first off I bought the product at a heavily discounted price here in the swiss market from a shop that was closing down, so the product was in their shelf for a long time. Thus te FW the RBK and RBS use as is default from the box is  V1.4.0.18 , and I am trying to update it to the latest.

        I read up the some prvious posts and thus tried to download the FW manually and then update the FW , but I keep getting "Please select correct configuration file" message and so am not able to upload the downloaded FW . What should I do? from my post it should be clear that I am a total noob at this, I was expectig an out of box and easy to setup/ pdate device...Please help