NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.

Forum Discussion

superczar's avatar
superczar
Apprentice
Oct 17, 2019

RBR50, RBS50 and RBS20 - Network being segmented?

I had a RBK50 (RBR50 and RBS50 ) that had been running fine for 2 years with a couple of firmware upgrades and minor woes in between. 

 

Yesterday I added a RBS 20 as a second satellite which is when I started getting weird issues.

 

Some of my LAN devices cannot see other LAN devices now ... e.g. PC A which is wired can ping RBK50 and RBS20 but not RBS20. However say device B can ping all 3.

 

The Orbi is running in AP mode with static IPs assigned to each Orbi.

The primary router (UBNT ER-X) can ping all 3 , each of the Orbis can ping each other just fine.

However several of the other devices can see only the RBK50 and 1 satellite.

 

The problem exists between devices also e.g. my phone that was connected to the RBS20 could not reach a wired LAN server although it could access the Internet just fine.

All 3 Orbis running the latest firmware.

 

Rough topology

 

WAN -> Router -> Switch (SG108E) -> RBR50 

The switch has other wired devices on it while the RBS20 and RBR50 have a non-daisy-chain link to the RBR50

 

One troubleshooting step that I did carry out was to scan the ARP table on the device that cannot ping RBR50 and noticed that no ARP entry for the RBR50 existed on it.

7 Replies

  • A good explanation, but the typos left me confused.  (too many RBS20's, not enough RBS50's).

     

    Could you please make a simple drawing showing exactly how the RBS50 and RBS20 connect to the RBR50?

    Are they wired directly to RBR50 LAN ports, or do either of them connect through the switch?

    • superczar's avatar
      superczar
      Apprentice

      Hopefully this makes more sense (See attached drawing).

       

      Testing just now after a full reset - For example, PC 1 can ping RBS20 but not RBS50

      However if I telnet into any of RBS20, RBS50 or RBR50 , they can all ping each other just fine

       

      • CrimpOn's avatar
        CrimpOn
        Guru

        Oh, my.  You can telnet into the RBS50, but cannot ping the RBS50?

        Can you open the RBS50 web page?