NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.

Forum Discussion

Shadow2359's avatar
Shadow2359
Aspirant
Dec 11, 2015

Slow Transfer Speed on Certain Files

Model : ReadyNAS 104

Configuration : Raid 0 (2x 1TB Drives)

Drives : Western Digital Blacks 1TB 7200RPM

HDD Tune Sector Scan and Smart Tests pass all green, read and write tests on drives show 146.9MB/sec | 15.9ms Access Time | 158.8 MB/sec Burst Rates

 

issue : Folder containing business critical information reads and writes at slow speeds (256KB/sec avg). After following other threads and discussions and trying balancing, scrubbing, defragging, firmware updates I managed to get the read and write speeds up a bit (2~3MB/sec), but this is still gonna be too slow for my users needs. 

 

What I tried : Moved all files onto my computers solid state drive and transfered to seperate internal hard disk drive, writes around 110MB/sec (I assume not an issue with the files themselves now) || Tried transfering a seperate file (5GB game file) to the NAS from my computer through the network which writes around 60MB/s (the NAS is capable of writing quickly) || Tried transfering the files to my Home NAS (I own one as well) which normally reads/writes between 20~35MB/sec however it gave same behavior as my customers NAS sending at about 2MB/sec || Tried connecting an external HDD 2.5" to the NAS directly via USB and transfer files through the NAS web browser utility however I can only assume the transfer rates are slow, it doesnt give me the data rates but the 30GB file size advised it would take 42 hours to finish

 

Folder Information : 30GB size | 350 folders | docx, xlsx, and pptx are the only file types in the folders

 

other thoughts : was hoping to get at least a 10MB/sec transfer rate, the issue is not isolated to slow data rates when transfering files but mainly with accessing them. My customer doesnt move files at all really, they just modify them. Opening windows explorer and going into the folder names is extremely slow and sometimes will time out. Once the files are open saving them will sometimes fail due to timeout error messages or file cannot be accessed message. I have a total of 4x 1TB drives but only 2x of them are used for data storage, the others were used as backup drives, the behavior is present on all drives, even external ones, also on my home NAS as well, any thoughts as to this would be most helpful. 

12 Replies

Replies have been turned off for this discussion
  • mdgm-ntgr's avatar
    mdgm-ntgr
    NETGEAR Employee Retired

    Well for starters you are using a home NAS. For business you should be using e.g. a 300 series or above NAS, if using a NAS for primary storage.

     

    Furthermore RAID-0 is strongly discouraged. If a single disk fails then all data on a RAID-0 volume using that disk is lost.

     

    How is the share on which you are storing this folder configured? Do you have snapshots enabled/disabled? What about bit-rot protection?

     

    Which protocol are you using to acces the NAS from the client machine and what OS is running on the client (e.g. SMB protocol and Windows 7 Professional client)?

     

    What services and apps are you running?

     

    What model is your home NAS? Is it also a 104, or something different? Is the configuration much the same for the share you tested with on your home NAS?

     

    Welcome to the Community!

     

    Can you send in the logs (see the Sending Logs link in my sig)?

    • Shadow2359's avatar
      Shadow2359
      Aspirant

      How is the share on which you are storing this folder configured? Do you have snapshots enabled/disabled? What about bit-rot protection?

           -No bit rot protection, snapshots set to Daily, SMB / FTP / HTTP are the only items enabled on the folder

       

      Which protocol are you using to acces the NAS from the client machine and what OS is running on the client (e.g. SMB protocol and Windows 7 Professional client)?

           -OS is Win 7 Professional and Win 8.1 Professional and Win 10, all three show same behavior

       

      What services and apps are you running?

          -currently none, when it was initially setup I had anti-virus app installed and the unit was set to a RAID 1, however I made sure to remove all of that and setup as RAID 0 to give best possible performance for testing

       

      What model is your home NAS? Is it also a 104, or something different? Is the configuration much the same for the share you tested with on your home NAS?

         -NAS 104 same model, configuration is not the same, x-raid with 2TB WD Greens with a bunch of apps installed on it

       

      emailing logs....

       

       

      • StephenB's avatar
        StephenB
        Guru - Experienced User

        What firmware is on the NAS?  What is the customer's network?  WiFi, fast ethernet, gigabit?

         

        Also, are SSD drives an option for the customer?  Since there are a lot of small files in these folders, SSD might boost performance.

         

         

NETGEAR Academy

Boost your skills with the Netgear Academy - Get trained, certified and stay ahead with the latest Netgear technology! 

Join Us!

ProSupport for Business

Comprehensive support plans for maximum network uptime and business peace of mind.

 

Learn More