VPN will not connect

Using comcast xfinity I have set up VPN using noip.com and port forwarded port 1194 on the router. 

 

However it will not connect using open vpn or does it detect the port 1194 can be hit, comcast firewall is off but it is still saying on the cable modem log the port is dropped, not sure f it is 1194 or not.

 

Anyone successfully set up the nighthawk vpn with comcast modem successfully and care to share the secret?

 

Thanks