NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.

Forum Discussion

naldo29's avatar
naldo29
Aspirant
Nov 20, 2020
Solved

Minecraft Server not working.

Basically I did the port foward like the video said, udp/tcp and 25565 and i chose my computer and everything but when i send my friend my public ip, it just doesnt work. I know that this is so vague and i might look dumb typing this but i got no where else to go. If yall need more info about my situation just aks and ill be glad to provide it. Thanks.

  • > And my internet port ip is 192.168.1.10

     

       Clearly not your public IP address.  (That's why "usual problem" "1"
    is number 1.)

     

    > [...] i dont have that much knowledge on it.

     

       I know almost nothing about it, but a quick Web search for that
    number suggests that it's "smart", which may not be ideal for this
    situation.

     

          https://dzsi.com/product/znid-gpon-2424a1/

     

       You might try searching around a little to see if this thing has a
    "bridge" (stupid) mode, which would disable its router functions.  Or if
    it's possible to do all the other stuff on its router, and configure the
    R6700v3 as a WAP.  But the router-ness of that gizmo is the source of
    the port-forwarding trouble when you're using the R6700v3-as-router with
    it.

     

       Ask your ISP?

10 Replies

  • > Basically [...]

     

       "Basically" is seldom the way a useful problem description begins.
    This one seems to be no exception.

     

    > [...] I did the port foward like the video said, [...]

     

       Oh!  "the video"!  I should watch "the video" to puzzle out what you
    did.  Thanks for not including a link.  I hate watching low-quality
    "instructional" movies, especially ones which apparently didn't do the
    job.

     

    > [...] when i send my friend my public ip, it just doesnt work. [...]

     

       "not work" is not a useful problem description.  It does not say what
    you did.  It does not say what happened when you did it.  As usual,
    showing actual actions (commands) with their actual results (error
    messages, LED indicators, ...) can be more helpful than vague
    descriptions or interpretations.

     

    > [...] I know that this is so vague and i might look dumb typing this
    > [...]


       You think?  Perhaps providing some useful information about what you
    did, and what happened when you did it, would work better.  Try to
    imagine that your reader wants to replicate what you did, and has no
    psychic powers, and, hence, can't see what you did or what happened when
    you did it.  Don't know what your "my friend" did, either, or what
    happened when he did that (whatever it was).

     

    > Model: R6700|Nighthawk AC1750 Smart WiFi Router

     

       Is that accurate?  Not an R6700v2 or R6700v3?  Look for "Model" on
    the product label.  Firmware version?  Connected to what?

     

       For the usual problems with port forwarding, see:

     

          https://community.netgear.com/t5/x/x/m-p/1859106

    • naldo29's avatar
      naldo29
      Aspirant

      Okay first its rev 3, second, i just didnt know what to include in it. V1.0.4.102_10.0.75 Connected to my pc via ethernet.

      When i said video i meant alot, basically what they said was to go to ipconfig, check what is deafult gateway and type it into the browser, next do the port fowarding. https://imgur.com/zHmBLHb. Then launch my minecraft server and i can join since i use localhost but my friend used my public ip but he got this. https://imgur.com/fVCuFSm
      If you want one of the vids that I used here it is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q0mFiBBVvnU
      Apart from this. I dont know what other info i could give you. I mean i tried one of those websites that check if your port foward worked with the minecraft port and it said it didnt or that it was "closed".
      If you need anything else im happy to give you more and sorry for the vauge message.

      • antinode's avatar
        antinode
        Guru

        > [...] Connected to my pc via ethernet.

         

           That's the unimportant part of the answer.  And to your ISP?

         

        > [...] https://imgur.com/zHmBLHb [...]

         

           LAN IP addresses like "10.0.0.x" suggest that your R6700v3 is
        connected to another router, which is a problem ("usual problem" "1")
        for port forwarding.

         

        > [...] i can join since i use localhost [...]

         

           That would be "usual problem" "3", if it had failed.

         

           Did _you_ try your "my public ip [address]"?  Did you try the
        WAN/Internet IP address of the R6700v3?  Did you look at "usual problem"
        "1"?

         

           What is your "my public ip [address]"?  If you're worried about
        revealing secrets, then the top half of an address, "a.b" out of
        "a.b.c.d", would satisfy most of my curiosity.


        > https://imgur.com/fVCuFSm

         

           "Connection refused" would be consistent with your friend talking to
        your other router.  (The one with no port forwarding configured.)

         

        > Apart from this. I dont know what other info i could give you. [...]

         

           I doubt that we need much more information for a diagnosis.  From
        what I can see, you appear to have cascaded two routers, and you're
        configuring port forwarding on the one which is not directly accessible
        from the outside world.  I'd expect that to fail ("usual problem" "1").

         

           Why do you have the R6700v3?  If the goal was better wireless-network
        coverage than you got from your (secret) other router, then you might
        want to configure the R6700v3 as a wireless access point, and configure
        your port forwarding on your (secret) other router.

         

           Visit http://netgear.com/support , put in your (actual) model number,
        and look for Documentation.  Get the User Manual.  Look for "Set Up the
        Router as a WiFi Access Point".


           Note that the (LAN) IP address of your Minecraft server (hence the
        server address in your port-forwarding rule) will be different (probably
        on a different subnet, even) when you change the R6700v3 from router
        mode to WAP mode.  Otherwise, knowing nothing about your (secret) other
        router, I can't tell you much about how to configure port forwarding on
        it.

         

           In any case, most likely, you'll want to reserve an address (on your
        (secret) other router) for your Minecraft server, so that it always
        agrees with your (new) port-forwarding rule.

         

           The alternative to the R6700v3-as-WAP would be to configure your
        (secret) other router as a modem-only (or eliminate it, if it's not a
        modem+router), and use the R6700v3 as your only router.  (I'd expect
        that scheme, too, to give you a different LAN IP subnet.)