NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.
I've been searching the forums and the Internet in general, today, as I have gotten my first notice from Comcast that, lo, I am over my 1 Terabyte limit, this month. It has been inching toward that mark for a bit, and last month was around 944 Gig. What can I say: We are a connected, gaming, streaming family and our Comcast link is a vital utility. I have seen suggestions on this forum to "just disconnect everything and reconnect until you find the hog." With 30ish devices on the network, 4 kids, 2 renters, and countless visitors, this is simply not a possibility. What I could do is set up a different router (preferably one with this feature) and move the connections over to it one-by-one until I find the offender. If I have to go that route, I highly doubt the Orbi would get reconnected. Which is a shame because it is a pretty decent solution for everything else.
I would like for Netgear to seriously consider giving customers an option for this data. There are many ways to do it, but ANY of them would be acceptable to me. I'm a long-time networking pro, so even if these are scary for some people, at least it would be an option.
- Do the metering in the device with display of the statistics in the interface and in the app. This is obviously going to make the most customers happy because it would give us a report per-device of the usage. This isn't rocket science: Even if the device has a database limitation of 100 devices to monitor, or even 50, it would be useful. COMCAST does it on their modem devices for xFi. It can't be that hard.
- Do the metering externally by providing SNMP statistics on a per-device basis for smaller timeframes. This would mean that the Orbi doesn't have to store "dead" devices forever and would be up to whatever stat-gathering tool was used.
- Do the metering externally by providing some app that collects the data to a desktop. Maybe Java so you can hit Windows, Linux, and Mac all at once with it.
- Provide traffic mirroring to a selected wired port. This would at least give me the ability to plug in Wireshark or other tools to see what is going on. It would be super useful for troubleshooting intermittent issues and not just bandwidth monitoring.
- Provide netflow/sflow output to a collector on the home network. This would also have broader uses than just bandwidth monitoring, but it is potentially the hardest to use solution in this list. If it is easy to implement in the Orbi (i.e., the chips already support it), then I'll take it happily.
- Other things I haven't mentioned. Look, I'm desperate, here. I will find a way to use anything that helps.
I get 2 months free "warnings" from Comcast, but the cost of not knowing this outweighs replacing the Orbi. Once I start getting charged $10/50 Gig, I'm going to need to know right then and there. And if I don't have a reasonable answer by that time, another Orbi will be going out to eBay.
195 Comments
Yes, please add this.
Same exact issues - over 1TB for the last 2 months - going to have to add an unlimited data plan at $50/month with Xfinity vs putting $150-$200 into a new router/mesh system. Have 2 satellites and plan to add 2 more and happy to give Netgear my $ as I've been loving Orbi - but now I'm stuck and cannot run a 1999 test each device one at a time method without dedicated days on end of sitting and starring No change in our home usage - no gaming - no 4k streaming - no new users or squatters - the conspiracy theory would be Orbi won't enable/add this feature b/c they know the 5g backbone transferring data between router and satellites is, in fact, using up data - beyond my pay grade - that said - I've scoured the web for answers/help - many many forums are noting this concern mostly in the past 3 months and nowhere has Netgear posted any acknowledgment they've heard this concern or that there is any roadmap plan. Prepared to give Netgear until year-end to address a plan and give Xfinity $50 for Dec for unlimited data - after that I'll be moving to a new system very sadly - have referred Orbi to lots for friends and family and sad to leave what was a great innovative (not mesh) product for a lesser but more user friendly solution.
Yes, please allow for per port/per device bandwidth monitoring.
So how come almost every Xfinity customer is reporting same issues over the last couple of months? I myself have passed the 2 month “courtesy”. I upgraded speeds and have 4K TV now. However, I’ve maybe streamed 1-2 movies during last two months. No other changes and my usage has spiked three fold. I also need to see what device is hogging the data. On a side note, my download in traffic meter shows as 1,480,000 MB last month!! How can that be? Isn’t that 11TB??
I have just recently experienced this same Data Usage problem with Comcast. For many, many months I used around 300GB of data. Then all of a sudden in July-August timeframe they turned-on Data Usage Monitoring and within two months my usage magically climbed to over 1.1TB. Our usage habits did not change. This is clearly a scam by Comcast to generate extra revenue. Netgear provides absolutely no help in combating this pillaging of their customers.
Monitoring data usage BY DEVICE is a requirement, not an option, now that Net Neutrality rules the land. Any Router vendor not providing that feature as a standard will soon be left behind.
+1 on per device data usage breakdown
So - just off the phone with Xfinity. Their suggestion: ditch the Netgear stuff because it doesnt support what's required to allow for "by device" usage - as does their other rental products. I think this is a pretty crappy answer, but NETGEAR PRODUCT TEAM - pay attention! Others are solving this problem and you are not. IT's growing more important for more cusotmers, and if you fail to address this need, you will find more and more users abandoning your otherwise great products. PLEASE consider the following user stories: 1) as a consumer, I need to be able to see data usage/bandwidth consumer by device in a granular enough fashion (hourly?) so I can manage my devices / so I can verify my internet service is charging me the right amount. 2) as a consumer, I need to be able to see internet usage by device (or family member) so I can turn off one device used by a certain teenager after they hit a usage quota (say 20GB/day) 3) as a consumer, I'd love to know what percentage of overall usage each internet streaming service is consuming (e.g. Amazon Music vs Netflix vs AppleTV . Got lots more - let me know if you're interested.
Agree. I think this is a good feature to have.
You may want to look into purchasing a Fingbox from fing.io
It gives you some capabilities to track down high-usage culprits and is on sale (Dec 2018) for around $80 US.
It also keeps track of all devices and is surprisingly feature-rich - considering
The FREE Fing mobile app gives you some initial functionality, but the Fingbox sits on your network at all times and can be accessed remotely from the mobile app or via a browser and allows you to perform bandwidth analysis on selected devices.
Hope this helps...
+1 for per device logging. also would be good to be able to bandwidth limit per device.
