× NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.
Orbi WiFi 7 RBE973
Reply

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

WojtekC
Guide

PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

Does the M4300-28G-PoE+ support PoE 802.3af with variant A or B, or maybe both?

A or B refers to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_over_Ethernet#Pinouts

I have PoE device which in particular requires PoE 802.3af variant A (+DC on pin 1 and 2, -DC on pin 3 and 6), and want to know, if it will work with this switch (that device is Ubiquiti UniFi Mesh UAP-AC-M).

Model: GSM4328PA|M4300-28G-PoE+ - 24x1G PoE+ Stackable Managed Switch with 2x10GBASE-T and 2xSFP+ (550W PSU)
Message 1 of 16
LaurentMa
NETGEAR Expert

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

Hi,

 

I believe this access point supports both Passive 24V ou Active 802.3af PoE modes and any standard PoE switch will work just fine in standard 802.3af mode. As such, the M4300 switches should be OK.

 

I hope this will help,

Regards,

Message 2 of 16
WojtekC
Guide

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

Thank You for a quick reply, but I still have doubts.

This device (UniFi AP) supports passive PoE, as stated in datasheet:

24V Passive PoE (Pairs 4, 5+; 7, 8 Return)

802.3af Alternative A (Pairs 1, 2+; 3, 6 Return)

So if switch will power device on pins 4,5;7,8 (variant B), may not detect it properly, or even damage by putting 50V, where 24V is expected.

If switch puts power on pins 1,2;3,6, then all should be fine. That's why is so important for me, which variant is implemented.

 

As a last resort solution is possible to connect device with only 1,2,3,6 pins, but then connection speed will be down to 100Mbit, what i want to avoid.

 

Message 3 of 16
LaurentMa
NETGEAR Expert

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

I think the access point manufacturer datasheet is leading to some confusion, and I can attest you will find many reports and feedback on other forums with this access point working fine with perfectly standard 802.3af switches.

Message 4 of 16
WojtekC
Guide

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

Thank You. I'll get the mentioned hardware in about month or so, then report back.

Message 5 of 16
schumaku
Guru

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B


@WojtekC wrote:

So if switch will power device on pins 4,5;7,8 (variant B), may not detect it properly, or even damage by putting 50V, where 24V is expected....  That's why is so important for me, which variant is implemented.


This problem isn't a problem, absolutley not important, and not applicable at all as long as using IEEE standards PoE standards: Different from most of these passive (dumb, cheap, ...) proprietary schemes, a 802.3af or 802.3at PoE source does not blindly supply any power without a proper negotiation to the PD (powered device).

Message 6 of 16
WojtekC
Guide

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B


@schumaku wrote:

@WojtekC wrote:

So if switch will power device on pins 4,5;7,8 (variant B), may not detect it properly, or even damage by putting 50V, where 24V is expected....  That's why is so important for me, which variant is implemented.


This problem isn't a problem, absolutley not important, and not applicable at all as long as using IEEE standards PoE standards: Different from most of these passive (dumb, cheap, ...) proprietary schemes, a 802.3af or 802.3at PoE source does not blindly supply any power without a proper negotiation to the PD (powered device).


I'm perfectly aware about that, and using non-standard device because it cheap, and know the risk.

As far as I know, standard compliant device can suply power with variant A or B, or even both. Just wanna know, how that standard is implemented in my particular switch. Unfortunately, nobody can tell so far.

Message 7 of 16
schumaku
Guru

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B


@WojtekC wrote:
As far as I know, standard compliant device can suply power with variant A or B, or even both.

Again: Unless there is a standard compliant PoE device plugged, NO power will be supplied by the switch. There is an (amazingly complex!) handshaking happen when a PoE device is plugged - before power will be supplied. 

 

Don't waste your time about a problem which does not exist on 802.11af and 802.11at swiches - they will power your UniFi without blackening them.

Message 8 of 16
schumaku
Guru

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

As we talk of PoE for Gigabit Ethernet where all four pairs are used for data ... the power is provided "in-band" anyway and the subject question obsolete.

Message 9 of 16
msi
Luminary
Luminary

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

I have 2 UAP-AC-M-PRO connected to a M4300-28G-PoE+, yes this is the bigger model that only supports 802.3af but I can say that this particular model does work as expected.

 

Other than that I agree with schumaku concerning the sensing that happens with PoE. It gets even more complex with PoE+... 😉

Message 10 of 16
WojtekC
Guide

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

Just wanna report, that Ubiquiti UniFi Mesh UAP-AC-M works with M4300-28G-PoE+.

Message 11 of 16
WojtekC
Guide

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

After testing a few M4300-28G-PoE+ with a dozen UAP-AC-M, I was experienced weird behavior, as described in this article: https://kb.netgear.com/000060427/How-do-I-troubleshoot-problems-with-my-NETGEAR-PoE-switch, near the end:

---------- quote --------

"On a switch with greater than 16 ports, a PD on Port 1 powers on but a PD on ports 2, 3 & 4 does not power on. Similarly, a PD on port 5 powers on but a PD on ports 6, 7 & 8 does not power on."

------

After switch reboot, all devices works O.K., but if I unplug device and plug it back, it is not powered. Only one from fourth devices is powered, and if I unplug that one, another one (just one) starts being powered and works.

 

Only workaround I can find is to connect device with patchcord with only pins 1,2,3,6 connected. Device is then instantly recognized and powered. You can also set port to 100Mbit full-duplex, with no auto negotiation, so device gets connected much quicker.

 

As article suggests i contacted support, but with no success so far...

 



 

Message 12 of 16
schumaku
Guru

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

@LaurentMa that's an odd problem in this switch class....

Message 13 of 16
LaurentMa
NETGEAR Expert

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

Hi @schumaku 

 

What is odd is not the switch here. The switch is fully compliant with 802.3af and 802.3at standards (hardware handshake and/or software handshake). One could blame proprietary third-party PD devices that are far from the standard, here? 

 

We will need tech-support file out of the switch when the problem occurs with standard patch cables in first place, I believe, to understand when the access point is deviating from the standard.

 

Regards,

Message 14 of 16
schumaku
Guru

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

Ohhhhhhh OK that's not what I wanted to say, sorry for this misunderstanding.

Message 15 of 16
WojtekC
Guide

Re: PoE 802.3af Standards A or B

As I said before, I am aware of all consequences from incompatibility of my devices, and prepared for all sort of problems.

Just found the mentioned article, and hoped, that if similar problem is already known, some solution also exists. I like to know that solution, even if problem mentioned in article is caused by standard-compliant devices, and some other switch.

I'll be happy to provide support file to my support ticked, if somebody ask.

Message 16 of 16
Top Contributors
Discussion stats
  • 15 replies
  • 8826 views
  • 3 kudos
  • 4 in conversation
Announcements