Re: Orbi AX6000 (RBK852) wireless vs wired

aster94 · ‎2020-05-11

Hello,

I recently bought a park of 3 Orbi. I sucessfully installed them and are working correctly.

I write because i have two questions:

1) I have the possibility to have them communicate in both wireless and wired (ethernet). Which is better, faster?

2) What happens if I turn off the power from a satelite or from the main router?

If I turn off the router would the satellite works the same?

if I turn off a satelite and another satelite is connecting to it via wireless wouldn't it be cut off?

Best regards

FURRYe38 · ‎2020-05-11

What Kildare said.

I prefer wired back haul as it's most stable. However 1000Mbs is the max link rate on eithernet for Orbi systems.

@aster94 wrote:
Spoiler
If you turn off the RBR, then RBS and devices connected to the RBS will no longer get internet services. RBS wireless or wired depend on the RBR being ON and connected to internet services.
So I can't turn off the RBR

Spoiler
You can either have the RBS wireless or wire connected. Not at the same time per RBS. You can have 1 RBS wirelessly connected and another RBS wired.
ok, but my question was different: I can have connected them in both ways, which should I choose? Isn't wired always better?

View solution in original post

FURRYe38 · ‎2020-05-11

@aster94 wrote:
Hello,

I recently bought a park of 3 Orbi. I sucessfully installed them and are working correctly.

I write because i have two questions:
1) I have the possibility to have them communicate in both wireless and wired (ethernet). Which is better, faster?
You can either have the RBS wireless or wire connected. Not at the same time per RBS. You can have 1 RBS wirelessly connected and another RBS wired.
https://kb.netgear.com/000051205/What-is-Ethernet-backhaul-and-how-do-I-set-it-up-on-my-Orbi-WiFi-Sy...

2) What happens if I turn off the power from a satelite or from the main router?
If I turn off the router would the satellite works the same?
if I turn off a satelite and another satelite is connecting to it via wireless wouldn't it be cut off?
If you turn off the RBR, then RBS and devices connected to the RBS will no longer get internet services. RBS wireless or wired depend on the RBR being ON and connected to internet services.

aster94 · ‎2020-05-11

Spoiler

If you turn off the RBR, then RBS and devices connected to the RBS will no longer get internet services. RBS wireless or wired depend on the RBR being ON and connected to internet services.

So I can't turn off the RBR

Spoiler

You can either have the RBS wireless or wire connected. Not at the same time per RBS. You can have 1 RBS wirelessly connected and another RBS wired.

ok, but my question was different: I can have connected them in both ways, which should I choose? Isn't wired always better?

kildare · ‎2020-05-11

@aster94 wrote:
ok, but my question was different: I can have connected them in both ways, which should I choose? Isn't wired always better?

From the specifications:

5GHz (2400Mbps†) dedicated WiFi link for faster data connections between Orbi Router and Orbi Satellite

Now 2400 Mbps are better than 1000 Mbps...

But only if the wireless backhaul quality is very good.

FURRYe38 · ‎2020-05-11

What Kildare said.

I prefer wired back haul as it's most stable. However 1000Mbs is the max link rate on eithernet for Orbi systems.

@aster94 wrote:
Spoiler
If you turn off the RBR, then RBS and devices connected to the RBS will no longer get internet services. RBS wireless or wired depend on the RBR being ON and connected to internet services.
So I can't turn off the RBR

Spoiler
You can either have the RBS wireless or wire connected. Not at the same time per RBS. You can have 1 RBS wirelessly connected and another RBS wired.
ok, but my question was different: I can have connected them in both ways, which should I choose? Isn't wired always better?

FURRYe38 · ‎2020-05-11

This is a test run with my ASUS GT-AX11000 wireless bridged to the RBR850. As you can see the connection rate is 2400Mpbs. The speed test maxes out since my ISP service is 1Gb and the LAN ports on the PC and the back of the ASUS is 1000Mpbs so we are seeing near or over 900Mpbs speeds on the down.

aster94 · ‎2020-05-12

Do you know how can i check the "link rate" you showed from your AX11000?

I would need to do somethink like that on my phone/laptop. If i run a normal speed test i get the same value because my ISP also limit my speed far away from the specified orbi transfer rate.

This is just for the sake of curiosity: anyway my final speed is limited, so I would probably end using the wired connection, the 1GBs limit is perfectly fine and my goal is stability

FURRYe38 · ‎2020-05-12

wifi sweet spots app on phone or pad works well to check the connection rate between the wireless devices and host wifi source.

kildare · ‎2020-05-12

@aster94 wrote:

I would need to do somethink like that on my phone/laptop. If i run a normal speed test i get the same value because my ISP also limit my speed far away from the specified orbi transfer rate.

To test your actual LAN/WIFI transfer rate you can use some apps, for ex.:

LAN Speed Test

https://totusoft.com/lanspeed

Only needed a shared folder.

aster94 · ‎2020-05-13

At the end i choosed to use the wired connection, the satellites are far and even if i didn't test the real wireless speed between them I doubt that I will ever notice any difference

FURRYe38 · ‎2020-05-13

You should be fine with wired RBS. Will have good performance with wired.

Enjoy.