Devices on VLANs can not reach defualt gatway. But able to ping from other subnet.

Not sure if this is here is where i should be posting but I can't find any information about this anywhere. So i got a M4100-50G a year ago from a computer recycler. I just ran it as a switch without any VLANs. Today I decied i wanted to work more with vlans and lags. My lab consists of a pfsense router, a Netgear M4100-50G, and some servers. I setup my vlans on pfsense through a lag and confirmed that the lag is up on both the switch and router. I then tagged my ports where i have my servers in the VLAN Membership tab and set the Port PVID to match it. For example: Server1 is connected to port 13. I set port 13 to Untagged (U), PVID to 50 and LAG1 as Tagged (T). Server1 has a ip of 192.168.50.3

So my issue is that i can ping Server1 from a subnet directly on the router, even remote in. But from within the server i can't reach the default gateway of the subnet. In pfsense it is setup as 192.168.50.1 for the subnet. I feel that this is a switch vlan issue as routing seems to be working above it.

Im open to any solutions!