NETGEAR is aware of a growing number of phone and online scams. To learn how to stay safe click here.

Forum Discussion

SteveAlliance's avatar
Nov 03, 2020
Solved

GS748Tv5 - Create an Internal and an External VLAN

Hi - a newbie here.  I am trying to configure a GS748Tv5 switch to have an internal and an external VLAN and am not having any luck.

 

Here's what I want to accomplish:

VLAN 1

Port 41 only.  I am currently connected to the switch using Port 41.  I am working remotely so I did not want to add it to the internal VLAN yet.

 

VLAN100 (External)

Ports 1 through 4.  Port 1 connects to my Comcast Router.  Ports 2 and 3 connect to my external Firewall ports.  Port 4 is empty.  Ports 1 through 4 are Tagged.

 

VLAN200 (Internal)

Ports 5 through 48.  Ports 5 through 46 are for my internal network (PC's, Printers, Projectors).  Ports 47 and 48 connect to my internal Firewall ports. Ports 5 through 40 and 42 through 46 are Untagged.  Ports 47 and 48 are Tagged

 

Here's what I have done:

1)The switch has a static IP address.

2) VLan 100 and 200 have been created and ports assigned.

3) PVID are configured.

 

And here is where my newbieness has me going crazy - I'm not sure how to configure the IP Routing on the VLans.  I do not have access to my current switch (which is an old Brocade) so I can't compare configurations for help. 

 

Do I route the external VLAN using my Comcast IP? 

I tried to add the Internal VLAN and it fails with a "Error! Failed to Set 'IP Address' with '192.168.xxx.x' " message.  (The xx.x was added by me on this email - I am using a valid internal address".

 

I'm hoping that someone can offer some advice on how I can get this configured.  Normally I would reach out to a contractor for this but becasue of the current world we are in he is not available to help me.

 

Appreciate any advice.

 

Thanks -

Steve

  • schumaku's avatar
    schumaku
    Nov 03, 2020

    Take it like this: A computer, printer, consumer router LAN is always untagged. The assignment of frames flowing into the switch to a VLAN is done by the PVID, the frames from the VLAN assigned coming from the switch to these devices are untagged.

3 Replies

  • schumaku's avatar
    schumaku
    Guru - Experienced User

    Hi Steve,

     

    Can't see why and where you want or need to install any VLAN routing - the connection between the subnets is up to your firewall device, not the switch.

     

    SteveAlliance wrote:

    VLAN100 (External)

    Ports 1 through 4.

    Port 1 connects to my Comcast Router.

    Ports 2 and 3 connect to my external Firewall ports.  Port 4 is empty.  Ports 1 through 4 are Tagged.


    Your Comcast router does work with tagged frames? Probably not.

     

    Your firewall WAN ports (why ever you want two) are configured for tagging, too?

     

    SteveAlliance wrote:

    VLAN200 (Internal)

    Ports 5 through 48.  Ports 5 through 46 are for my internal network (PC's, Printers, Projectors).  Ports 47 and 48 connect to my internal Firewall ports. Ports 5 through 40 and 42 through 46 are Untagged.  Ports 47 and 48 are Tagged


    Your firewall WAN ports (why ever you want two) are configured for tagging, too?

     

    Both switch networks (VLANs) are simple L2 networks in this set-up.

    • SteveAlliance's avatar
      SteveAlliance
      Aspirant

      schumaku  -

       

      This is where my newbieness rears it's head - The ports were tagged because from what I garnered from the online help it sounded like they should be. IP Routing done for the same reason.  We have multiple internal and external firewall ports because of a redundant firewall solution.

       

      I will untag the ports and delete the IP routing  and see what happens when I plug things in on Saturday.

       

      Thanks for the feedback!

      • schumaku's avatar
        schumaku
        Guru - Experienced User

        Take it like this: A computer, printer, consumer router LAN is always untagged. The assignment of frames flowing into the switch to a VLAN is done by the PVID, the frames from the VLAN assigned coming from the switch to these devices are untagged.

NETGEAR Academy

Boost your skills with the Netgear Academy - Get trained, certified and stay ahead with the latest Netgear technology! 

Join Us!

ProSupport for Business

Comprehensive support plans for maximum network uptime and business peace of mind.

 

Learn More