This topic has been marked solved and closed to new posts due to inactivity. We hope you'll join the conversation by posting to an open topic or starting a new one.
Uncorrectable errors reported but drive status is shown as OK
About a week ago (March 😎 I started getting alerts on one of my two 4TB Seagate NAS HDD ST4000N000 drives. Since then I've been getting an increasing amount of alerts, the latest one stating:
Detected increasing uncorrectable errors[336] on disk 1 [ST4000VN000-1H4168, Z3064V0L]. This often indicates an impending failure. Please be prepared to replace this disk to maintain data redundancy.
I'm preparing to replace the drive, but I have a question about how the drive status is reported in the web interface.
The Disk icon at the bottom of the interface is green, and when I hover over the icon both disks show as green as well. When I look at Status > Health, both disks are green, and have OK in their Status column. That seems counterintuitive given the alerts I'm receiving, and misleading.
The SMART+ report effectively shows:
Reported Uncorrect
16
Current Pending Sector
336
Offline Uncorrectable
336
ATA Error Count
16
I can understand that the Volume icon is green since technically no disk has failed (yet), but I would expect to see the disk that's generating the alerts to at least show as yellow (like the blinking yellow icon next to the alerts in the log).
I'm using RAIDiator-x86 version 4.2.30 (which appears to be the latest version available for my device).
Am I wrong in expecting to see the (close to) failing disk as yellow and not green, and not see OK in its Status column?
I can understand that the Volume icon is green since technically no disk has failed (yet), but I would expect to see the disk that's generating the alerts to at least show as yellow (like the blinking yellow icon next to the alerts in the log).
This icon shows the status of the RAID members. As the HDD is still a synced member of the RAID array, it's green.
From memory, it becomes blinking yellow during resync.
That's the design of the "RAIDiator 4" system.
That said, I agree that it could be clearer, with something like a little warning road sign or something. But as the product is End of Life, I don't think this will ever be changed. I'm not even sure there is an icon somewhere showing a different color when there are "just" errors on a HDD is "ReadyNAS OS6" system (the current one). Sill on OS6, these are the, imho insane, levels for the email alerts: https://kb.netgear.com/30046/ReadyNAS-OS-6-Disk-Failure-Alerting
I can understand that the Volume icon is green since technically no disk has failed (yet), but I would expect to see the disk that's generating the alerts to at least show as yellow (like the blinking yellow icon next to the alerts in the log).
This icon shows the status of the RAID members. As the HDD is still a synced member of the RAID array, it's green.
From memory, it becomes blinking yellow during resync.
That's the design of the "RAIDiator 4" system.
That said, I agree that it could be clearer, with something like a little warning road sign or something. But as the product is End of Life, I don't think this will ever be changed. I'm not even sure there is an icon somewhere showing a different color when there are "just" errors on a HDD is "ReadyNAS OS6" system (the current one). Sill on OS6, these are the, imho insane, levels for the email alerts: https://kb.netgear.com/30046/ReadyNAS-OS-6-Disk-Failure-Alerting
