× NETGEAR will be terminating ReadyCLOUD service by July 1st, 2023. For more details click here.
Orbi WiFi 7 RBE973
Reply

EDA500 connecting directly to PC

Caesarea
Guide

EDA500 connecting directly to PC

Before I order the EDA500 Expansion Chassis 5-Bay I want to verify if I can connect the EDA500 directly to my PC with Windows 10.

 

Can anybody help me with this?

Is there any compatibity list with the EDA500?

 

Thank you!

Model: EDA500|ReadyNAS Expansion Chassis 5-Bay
Message 1 of 43

Accepted Solutions
Caesarea
Guide

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

The combination EDA500 and StarTech.com 2-port SATA 6 Gbit/s PCI Express eSATA (PEXESAT32) WORKS!!!

 

But if you connect the second EDA500 to the second port of the PCI, it does NOT work.

 

Good luck to you all.

 

Thanks for the responses!

View solution in original post

Message 34 of 43

All Replies
StephenB
Guru

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

It's designed to be connected to specific ReadyNAS models.  

 

I've never heard of anyone whose used it with a Windows PC.

Message 2 of 43
Caesarea
Guide

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

Thanks, So, I understand it is maybe possible. I think the EDA500 is like a dockingstation, it should be possible. Any feedback if I am wrong.

Message 3 of 43
StephenB
Guru

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

Certainly Netgear did not design it to be a general esata expansion, so I wouldn't go as far as saying it "should be possible"

 

I suspect the port on the PC would have to support the sata Port Multiplier functionality at the very least..

Message 4 of 43
Caesarea
Guide

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

My PC is connected with a USB 3.0 cable with the Belkin aluminium 4-poorts USB 3.0-hub, this hub is connected with 4 USB-drives and my PC can see 4 different USB-drives.

 

Why shouldn't see the EDA500 5 different HDD's if I connect the EDA500 (with 5 HDD's) directly to a SATA-port on the motherboard? 

Or is there a esata-lock implented by Netgear? The latter I couldn't read anywhere.

 

 

Message 5 of 43
sotrack
Luminary

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

Just connect the EDA500 to PC and check.

Message 6 of 43
Caesarea
Guide

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

As mentioned before I don't have any yet. I want to be sure before I buy 2 of these expensive products 😉

Message 7 of 43
Sandshark
Sensei

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC


@Caesarea wrote:

Thanks, So, I understand it is maybe possible. I think the EDA500 is like a dockingstation, it should be possible. Any feedback if I am wrong.


Why do you insist that "it should be possible".. Netgear could have designed it that way, but did not.  Might it still work that way in spite of not being designed to do so?  Yes.  Should it?  I wouldn't go that far.  Since there are ReadyNAS devices other than those listed as compatible with the EDA500 that have an eSATA port, I think it safer to assume that there is some kind of limitation enforced until somone proves otherwise.

 

Not every eSATA port supports port multiplication, so that could also be a limitation for your use.  USB and eSATA are very different and your assumption that one should work like the other is not a good one.

Message 8 of 43
sotrack
Luminary

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

RN316 is more effective than EDA500. Price ~ the same

Message 9 of 43
Sandshark
Sensei

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

There are some pretty cheap EDA500's on eBay right now.

Message 10 of 43
Caesarea
Guide

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

Before I buy one (cheapest on eBay to The Netherlands = € 200) I want tbe sure I can connect it to my PC and see all the HDDs on my PC

Message 11 of 43
StephenB
Guru

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC


@Sandshark wrote:

There are some pretty cheap EDA500's on eBay right now.


US Amazon pricing for a new one is about $125.  An RN316 is much more.

 

I have no need for one, but the price is tempting.

Message 12 of 43
Caesarea
Guide

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

I guess the EDA500 eSATA port has a port-multplier functionality. So maybe I can combine the Startech® 2 Port PCI-Express eSATA Controller Adapter Card (PEXESATA2) with the EDA500?

Message 13 of 43
Caesarea
Guide

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

Found some pictures of the EDA500:

 

Front.jpg

 

 

Front1.jpg

 

Back1.jpg

 

Afbeelding3.jpg

 

Back3.jpg

 

Back4.jpg

Message 14 of 43
StephenB
Guru

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC


@Caesarea wrote:

I guess the EDA500 eSATA port has a port-multplier functionality. So maybe I can combine the Startech® 2 Port PCI-Express eSATA Controller Adapter Card (PEXESATA2) with the EDA500?


Maybe being the key word.

 

This isn't an intended use of the EDA500, and so far no EDA500 owner has chimed in to say whether it works or not.

 

 

Message 15 of 43
Caesarea
Guide

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

So, should I try and update you? Or should I stop trying to use the EDA500 like I want to use as a dockingstation?
Message 16 of 43
StephenB
Guru

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC


@Caesarea wrote:
So, should I try and update you? Or should I stop trying to use the EDA500 like I want to use as a dockingstation?

I think there are other people here who would like to know if this works.  So if you choose to do a risk buy, please do post back.

 

Note that none of the folks posting on this thread work for Netgear (the Netgear folks who are active here haven't commented).

 

BTW, one of the EDA500 bays isn't electrically connected to the SATA bus - it is intended to hold a spare.  So it's really a 5-bay unit with a storage slot.

Message 17 of 43
Caesarea
Guide

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

Totally, there are 6 bay which one has no SATA connection as you can see at one of the photos.

Then it is a 5-bay unit with a storage slot, isn't it?

I will try and post back/update...
Message 18 of 43
StephenB
Guru

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC


@Caesarea wrote:



Then it is a 5-bay unit with a storage slot, isn't it?

Yes - I've fixed my earlier post.

 

FWIW, there is a brief hardware overview here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=osAZODdTodo

Message 19 of 43
Caesarea
Guide

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

I almost sure it has, but can somebody confirm the eSATA port of the EDA500 has port-multplier functionality? 

 

I ordered the EDA500 for a very good price and also ordered the Startech® 2 Port PCI-Express eSATA Controller Adapter Card (PEXESATA2).

 

I will receive it next week, hopefully...

Message 20 of 43
Emachine
Aspirant

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

I bought also that kind of NAS from Ibood.

 

Bought and eSATA card to put in the pc, it doens't recognize

 

Seems this NAS only work when it's conected to an other NetGear Nas like 

This release of ReadyNAS OS supports the following ReadyNAS systems: • ReadyNAS 102 • ReadyNAS 104 • ReadyNAS 202 • ReadyNAS 204 • ReadyNAS 212 • ReadyNAS 214 • ReadyNAS 312

Message 21 of 43
jak0lantash
Mentor

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC


@Emachine wrote:

I bought also that kind of NAS from Ibood.

 

Bought and eSATA card to put in the pc, it doens't recognize

 

Seems this NAS only work when it's conected to an other NetGear Nas like 

This release of ReadyNAS OS supports the following ReadyNAS systems: • ReadyNAS 102 • ReadyNAS 104 • ReadyNAS 202 • ReadyNAS 204 • ReadyNAS 212 • ReadyNAS 214 • ReadyNAS 312


EDA500 is not a NAS, it's an expansion chassis.

And among the ReadyNAS models you listed, only the RN312 is compatible.

http://www.netgear.ie/business/products/storage/readynas/readynas-desktop.aspx#tab-expansion

 

Maybe you want to look at purchasing a DAS, which sounds closer to want you're looking for.

Message 22 of 43
Emachine
Aspirant

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

when I buy a nas RN 102, is than the problem solved ?

 

http://www.downloads.netgear.com/files/GDC/datasheet/en/RN100.pdf

 

Thanks in advance

 

Luc

Message 23 of 43
jak0lantash
Mentor

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

What problem exactly?
RN102 does not support EDA500.
(If you have an issue not related to EDA500, please create another thread.)
Message 24 of 43
Emachine
Aspirant

Re: EDA500 connecting directly to PC

I have an EDA500  and when I buy an RN312 model, all is ok ?

 

I hope than I can acces my drives into the EDA 500

 

Thanks

 

Luc

Message 25 of 43
Top Contributors
Discussion stats
  • 42 replies
  • 7762 views
  • 2 kudos
  • 7 in conversation
Announcements