RN104 degraded, replaced drive and new drive degraded
Please help....
Readynas RN104 4 x 2TB Seagate NAS hard drives
Problem :2nd Volume degraded, seemed to happen after firmware update, I replaced the degraded volume with same size and type HDD, after system went through rebuild it now says Volume 2 degraded. any suggestions much appreciated. I've only had this system less than 6 months.
Re: RN104 degraded, replaced drive and new drive degraded
robbigelow wrote:
Please help....
Readynas RN104 4 x 2TB Seagate NAS hard drives
Problem :2nd Volume degraded, seemed to happen after firmware update, I replaced the degraded volume with same size and type HDD, after system went through rebuild it now says Volume 2 degraded. any suggestions much appreciated. I've only had this system less than 6 months.
Cheers Rob
I mean that you have described your setup as having a 2nd volume, and the nas saying that Volume 2 is degraded. This implied to me that there is a Volume 1 and a volume 2; in other words that your setup is not the default raid 5, but perhaps 2 separate volumes. I am now thinking you are using the word "volume" instead of "disk" The readynas uses degraded to describe a volume that is still intact but is no longer redundant. A disk that has died is described as dead.
Clearly you have moved on from this now, and it appears that a disk was faulty and the replacement may be problematic too.
Re: RN104 degraded, replaced drive and new drive degraded
vandermerwe wrote:
robbigelow wrote:
Please help....
Readynas RN104 4 x 2TB Seagate NAS hard drives
Problem :2nd Volume degraded, seemed to happen after firmware update, I replaced the degraded volume with same size and type HDD, after system went through rebuild it now says Volume 2 degraded. any suggestions much appreciated. I've only had this system less than 6 months.
Cheers Rob
I mean that you have described your setup as having a 2nd volume, and the nas saying that Volume 2 is degraded. This implied to me that there is a Volume 1 and a volume 2; in other words that your setup is not the default raid 5, but perhaps 2 separate volumes. I am now thinking you are using the word "volume" instead of "disk" The readynas uses degraded to describe a volume that is still intact but is no longer redundant. A disk that has died is described as dead.
yeh, im a bit confused on the terminology, says volume is degraded but Disk 2 state is failed
Clearly you have moved on from this now, and it appears that a disk was faulty and the replacement may be problematic too.
Re: RN104 degraded, replaced drive and new drive degraded
Robbiegelow - You are saying your current volume status is degraded (with disk 2 failed)? That is, the replacement disk didn't solve the problem?
If so, either your replacement also failed, or there is something wrong with your RN104 hardware (perhaps an SATA bus issue). The best way to proceed is to try testing the disk with the NAS boot option. Then also test on a PC using seatools. If both fail, then you have a bad replacement. If the NAS fails and the PC says the disk is good, then you likely have problem with your RN104 hardware.
On the PC test - you can use a USB dock or USB adapter kit, or (if a desktop) temporarily install the disk internally (leaving your normal hard drives installed of course). If you have a PC with an eSata connection, you can also use the power supply from the USB adapter kit and a sata->eSata cable (which is what I generally do).
If both pass, the you probably need to contact Netgear support (even if they charge).
Re: RN104 degraded, replaced drive and new drive degraded
StephenB wrote:
Robbiegelow - You are saying your current volume status is degraded (with disk 2 failed)? That is, the replacement disk didn't solve the problem?
If so, either your replacement also failed, or there is something wrong with your RN104 hardware (perhaps an SATA bus issue). The best way to proceed is to try testing the disk with the NAS boot option. Then also test on a PC using seatools. If both fail, then you have a bad replacement. If the NAS fails and the PC says the disk is good, then you likely have problem with your RN104 hardware.
On the PC test - you can use a USB dock or USB adapter kit, or (if a desktop) temporarily install the disk internally (leaving your normal hard drives installed of course). If you have a PC with an eSata connection, you can also use the power supply from the USB adapter kit and a sata->eSata cable (which is what I generally do).
If both pass, the you probably need to contact Netgear support (even if they charge).
Thanks StephenB, I'll give that a go, I've ordered a USB dock as I currently don't own a desktop pc either, probably a week or so before I get it. very much appreciated, cheers Rob
Re: RN104 degraded, replaced drive and new drive degraded
robbigelow wrote:
StephenB wrote:
Robbiegelow - You are saying your current volume status is degraded (with disk 2 failed)? That is, the replacement disk didn't solve the problem?
If so, either your replacement also failed, or there is something wrong with your RN104 hardware (perhaps an SATA bus issue). The best way to proceed is to try testing the disk with the NAS boot option. Then also test on a PC using seatools. If both fail, then you have a bad replacement. If the NAS fails and the PC says the disk is good, then you likely have problem with your RN104 hardware.
On the PC test - you can use a USB dock or USB adapter kit, or (if a desktop) temporarily install the disk internally (leaving your normal hard drives installed of course). If you have a PC with an eSata connection, you can also use the power supply from the USB adapter kit and a sata->eSata cable (which is what I generally do).
If both pass, the you probably need to contact Netgear support (even if they charge).
Thanks StephenB, I'll give that a go, I've ordered a USB dock as I currently don't own a desktop pc either, probably a week or so before I get it. very much appreciated, cheers Rob
I managed to get a usb dock and ran seatools, both the old and new disk fail the tests..... guess is a warranty claim for the disks. Thanks for your help
